Beginner "What bike should I get?" Thread

PB Forum :: Beginners

Beginner "What bike should I get?" Thread

Author Message
Posted: Jul 17, 2012 at 5:32 Quote
YT tues or a canyon torque 6.0 ????

Posted: Jul 17, 2012 at 18:21 Quote
I bought the Giant Revel 0 (2012 model). I get it Friday/Saturday Big Grin Big Grin

Posted: Jul 17, 2012 at 19:14 Quote
GoingLikeABoeing wrote:
I bought the Giant Revel 0 (2012 model). I get it Friday/Saturday Big Grin Big Grin

its a recreational bike. really depends which type of riding u do.

Posted: Jul 18, 2012 at 6:04 Quote
kencamarador wrote:
GoingLikeABoeing wrote:
I bought the Giant Revel 0 (2012 model). I get it Friday/Saturday Big Grin Big Grin


its a recreational bike. really depends which type of riding u do.

well, I'm new to MTB so I think it should be a good start. Component wise it's a good value that's for sure.

Posted: Jul 19, 2012 at 9:55 Quote
2007 Ellsworth Dare? the add says it's good, but needs a shock rebuild, how much would that cost? i'm an intermediate downhiller, but i'm still learning about the tech, and if you want i could post the add.

Posted: Jul 19, 2012 at 10:00 Quote
yes please post the add

Posted: Jul 19, 2012 at 10:05 Quote
so here's the add, http://sfbay.craigslist.org/nby/bik/3137175931.html
I think it doesn't look bad, but i don't know anything about forks, rebuilds, and so i wanted another opinion.
Element30kid wrote:
yes please post the add

Posted: Jul 19, 2012 at 10:10 Quote
looks nice a chainring will run you 30 bucks and i googled the shock and it must be a typo cause ive never heard of bomic and neither has google so id look into that but generally speaking a rebuild kit for my rp23 was 17 bucks and took me 45 mins and its like as 30 dollar cost at your lbs for labour

Posted: Jul 19, 2012 at 10:14 Quote
Sweet! thank you! I think they might mean bomber? but i'm not sure, and thank you for the info about shock rebuilds!
Element30kid wrote:
looks nice a chainring will run you 30 bucks and i googled the shock and it must be a typo cause ive never heard of bomic and neither has google so id look into that but generally speaking a rebuild kit for my rp23 was 17 bucks and took me 45 mins and its like as 30 dollar cost at your lbs for labour

Posted: Jul 19, 2012 at 11:07 Quote
It's a romic shock.

Posted: Jul 19, 2012 at 11:16 Quote
Romic.

Edit: Posted without looking. Beat me to it.

Posted: Jul 23, 2012 at 12:01 Quote
Hey all

I'm trying to get a first mtb to do some trail/xc riding. I've been riding road since january and my fitness is pretty good. My budget is $1000-$1500, so I was thinking of getting a hardtail 29er

Would something like the Santa Cruz Highball Aluminum D be a good choice? Anything else good in this price range? Thanks

Posted: Jul 25, 2012 at 9:43 Quote
Stumpy FSR Comp or Santa Cruz Blur LT (R AM Kit) or?...

Overall, I'm looking for a solid trail bike. The local terrain definitely comes down more on the XC side of things but I do plan to make the occasional 2 hour drive to some gravity fed/DH-ish trails as well. I realize no bike will last long without regular and thorough maintenance, but yes, I am also lazy and my wrench skills have seen better days so maintenance difficulty is a consideration for me.

3k USD is the absolute upper bound of my budget (hoping to catch the Blur on sale during the off-season if that is what I end up going for). My LBS carries Specialized, Santa Cruz, and Kona and I plan to testride but they certainly have their favorites and I would like some unbiased perspective.

Regarding my background: I used to ride in high school... a lot... that was some 10, 15 years ago though. Now I'm all grown up at 6'1" and 160lbs. I recently licked blood again when a friend moved abroad and I got his old bike. I know that I will stick with this for a few years, maybe even do some recreational rider races, so I am OK dropping a bit more than one would on a just getting started bike in hopes that it will save me some coin in the long run.

Posted: Jul 25, 2012 at 11:58 Quote
So what do you want this bike for? XC or DH? I mean if you want to take an XC bike DH go for it, but you will break stuff. Be it you or the bike. You can take a DH or FR bike on XC trails ... but #1 its overkill and #2 it's going to be heavy.

That said the bikes you chose are more of a middle ground, around 120mm-140mm travel so its more of an All Mountain category. If you were going to chose a NEW bike out of those brands, Specialized, Santa Cruz, and Kona, I'd go for the Santa Cruz Nomad (that's my personal preference). Its going to rock those DH style trails, not break and still be able to be pressed into service on XC trails. That said, the Blur isn't a bad choice either and for you may be the best choice. Slightly less travel, but less $$ too. It will do better on the XC than the Nomad, but a little less so on the DH trails than the Nomad too.

The stumpy is going to be great for XC, but it is less travel and steeper head angle make it a bit sketchy on DH. And blah blah blah ... everyone likes/has stumpies ... blah blah blah.

I've ridden both the Nomad and the Blur and the Stumpy on the same style trails, and I'd rate them in that order of best to worse. Truthfully if you are spending that much on your first bike I would ride them all. A worthwhile shop will let you do more than a ride around the parking lot and have demo's available. TRY THEM ALL. Anyone here can tell you all day what you should do, but what is right for you will be what you like the most on the trail. And you shouldn't decide any other way.

Posted: Jul 25, 2012 at 13:22 Quote
Well yeah, middle ground is definitely what I'm fishing for (i.e. Trail/All Mountain). If push comes to shove XC will factor more than DH capability (65/35 importance) but again, I want something that won't snap because I take it down a bit of chatter every once in a while either. As for the Nomad I definitely considered it but at 3.5k it's significantly above my max price point.

Thank you for the feedback though.


Copyright © 2000 - 2013. Pinkbike.com. All rights reserved.
dv43 0.018777