That is my opinion... I think that although what your are doing has some thought behind it and may indeed be a good idea, that proper gusting, welding, and engineering into the thickness of the materials, location and shapes of tubes/gussets do at least an equally good job. You could still have a failure with a "wrap around" gusset like you have, granted it may take more force, but it may also stiffen up the head tube junction to the point where it increases stresses just past the weld points of the gussets on the top tube and down tube. So it's possible you could just be moving the failure point.
That is my opinion... I think that although what your are doing has some thought behind it and may indeed be a good idea, that proper gusting, welding, and engineering into the thickness of the materials, location and shapes of tubes/gussets do at least an equally good job. You could still have a failure with a "wrap around" gusset like you have, granted it may take more force, but it may also stiffen up the head tube junction to the point where it increases stresses just past the weld points of the gussets on the top tube and down tube. So it's possible you could just be moving the failure point.
this is what i wanted to hear, yes, untreated metal may collaps are the end of the weld seem, indeed, this will push me to make sure that all future production will be heat treated and use a combination of stainless steel hardox 420 , this steel weld very well , but has the resiliance of spring steel, so i hope my next production will meet a new level of standart and lifetime warranty,
Okay, so here is bike number 2, Just starting to put it together. here are a couple pictures of the design and my approach at a jig. i have access to a big cnc router which works well for jig making.
Got the size large how I want it. The old front tri was too raked out ended up at 60-61 HA which was to much. Changed the headtube to EC49 on the bottom. Had a ZS56 fail on another bike not a fan of them. Changed the swing arm yoke area and added a mandrel bent bottom tube. Pretty stoked how it turned out at happy to leave it in the shed with the ALTED name on it. Have some suspension tuning to do, is tricky to get a feel for it wilth limited runs when pushing back to the top. Thanks for the nice posts on the pics I put up over the weekend.
Proper engineering of a frame, lab testing and we've got a solid frame. Most frames have a 5 yr warranty.
Why would you want a lifetime warranty? It's just a pure gimmick. People buy new bikes. Warranties aren't transferable, plus what defines a warranty. You bin your bike into the woods at high speed, land some 360° at 270° and you crack a stay, are those things warranty?
Wow! The last few ones look really nice! To bad that in europe hardly anyone is willing to make some nice Cromo frames.... I wish you guys good success in your projects!
oi stop trollin you douchebags, docZ has been her waaaaay longer than almost anyone and probably made more frames than 95% of the peeps who think thay can somehow contribute to this thread whithout ever actually having made a frame.
whether or not you like his frames or his welding skills, the fact is that unless you make one yourself, you have no right to pass judgement. i used to stick weld up mild steel frames too and everyone gave me shit for years, now i sell loads of frames every year to people all around the world. this aint no forum for trolls.