Camelbak Skyline 10 LR Hydration Pack - Review

May 16, 2016 at 13:28
by David Arthur  
Camelbak Skyline


Camelbak is the Hoover of the hydration pack market, and while there may be many pretenders to the throne, constant innovation ensures that they will not be displaced. Camelbak released a new lowrider hydration pack last fall, in the shape of the all-new Skyline 10 LR (and the women-specific Solstice) and it’s one of the best hydration trail packs I’ve yet tested. With outstandingly good stability and comfort. this is the pack for people who normally can’t stand wearing a hydration pack..


The Skyline differs from conventional hydration packs in that, in place of a tall, narrow bladder sitting vertically on the entire back, it employs a wider, shorter bladder that sits low around the waist. The Skyline features Camelbak's Antidote three-liter bladder, accessed from a zipped back panel, and a removable hose that makes cleaning duties simpler. The pack's seven-liter cargo capacity is enough for the majority of trail rides, with the main compartment containing mesh pockets and a removable tool roll to keep essentials organized. Outside, there’s a large compressible compartment for stashing a jacket, a smaller soft-lined pocket at the top (ideal for eyewear or a smartphone), and there are two additional pockets on the hip belt. A helmet and body armor can be stowed on the outside.

Details:

• 3L lumbar bladder
• 7L total storage capacity
• Main storage pocket with mesh compartments
• Fleece-lined media pocket
• Waist belt pockets
• Helmet hook
• Bike tool organizer roll
• XV Multi-Layer EVA foam back panel
• Colors: black, ember, blue
• Weight: 995g
• MSRP: $130 USD
• Contact: Camelbak



Camelbak Skyline
Wide hip belts and generous padding supports the pack on your back.

Camelbak Skyline
The three-liter bladder is easily accessed via the zipped back panel.



Performance

The biggest advantage the Skyline offers over conventional hydration packs is increased comfort and stability due to the better weight distribution of the low-slung reservoir. Even with a fully loaded bladder, the pack never feels unwieldy or cumbersome, even when negotiating steep and technical trails. The design of the Skyline massively improves stability over conventional packs and it's far more comfortable.

The water reservoir - the heaviest cargo - is situated down low, which removes the load from your shoulders and places it around your hips. The wide padded hip belt is keeps everything in place and does it comfortably, without excessive tightness. The shoulder straps are really just there to stabilize the pack. The Skyline doesn’t move about, or try to strangle you when dropping into a steep chute. The vented back and shoulder strap padding meant riding in warm weather resulted in a less soggy jersey than I was used to.


Camelbak Skyline
Main compartment features several mesh pockets for organizing essentials.

Camelbak Skyline
Hose is kept secure with neat magnetic holder, but it could be easier to use.

It’s a well-appointed pack, with everything in the right place to make it easy to live with. Camelbak’s bite valve delivers big gulps of water when you need it and the valve can be locked for travelling to prevent leakage. There’s a magnetic hook on the strap which stops it from flapping about, but it’s not as easy to use as Osprey’s excellent magnetic tube attachment system. Accessing the bladder is super easy, as it’s stored inside a zipped panel at the back, and the handle integrated into the reservoir lid hooks into a slot in the compartment to keep it locked in place.

In addition to transporting three-liters of water in the Skyline, there's enough space for a spare tube, pump, tool, some food, and a lightweight jacket, but the pack never felt heavy or cumbersome. People wanting a pack for epic days in the hills might want to look to a bigger pack, but I found there was just enough space for everything I needed for most reasonable distance rides, without the bulk of a bigger pack that would tempt you into taking more stuff than you really need. The Skyline is about minimal packing, travelling light and fast.



Pinkbike's Take:
bigquotes Camelbak's Skyline is an impressively comfortable hydration pack that suits trail riders because it is ultra-stable and lightweight. There's just enough space for essential spares, but not so much that you're tempted to take the kitchen sink. For most trail riders, the Skyline's lean profile and low-slung weight make it a standout product in a crowded category. It's a brilliant trail hydration pack. - David Arthur



Visit the high-res gallery for more images from this review.




Author Info:
davidarthur avatar

Member since Apr 12, 2015
73 articles
Must Read This Week
Sign Up for the Pinkbike Newsletter - All the Biggest, Most Interesting Stories in your Inbox
PB Newsletter Signup

75 Comments
  • 18 2
 I actually switched from my Osprey Raptor 10 to this pack. The lower wider bladder placement really makes a big difference in keeping the weight lower and more stable. I got the more subdued black and blue version.
  • 6 1
 They used the same design on this thing's big brother, the Volt 13. Love it, not having several kilos of water sloshing round my neck on every descent is a luxury I'd never even thought about.
  • 2 2
 When I bought the Osprey Raptor 10 it was the sh*t, and I still love it, but this new Camelbak is making me look hard at my next pack.

I really like the tool roll on the Raptor though. And the magnetic bite valve system is still better with the Osprey.

I usually only fill with 1L of water, unless it's super hot or it's gonna be a long ride. So the weight isn't too much of an issue.
  • 3 2
 @Endurahbrah: Don't worry, Osprey isn't one to rest on their laurels. if this concept proves itself, they'll have one available.
  • 2 0
 @Endurahbrah: Yeah the CB has a tool roll too. Agreed on the magnetic clip. I swapped mine over from the Osprey. Smile
  • 1 0
 Are you finding you are able to organize gear as well with the Skyline? I am comparing to the Raptor 10 and the skyline seems to hold half the gear if I want it to be comfortably accessible. The volume for the main pocket is decent but just seems impossible to really organize. Can't decide whether I'll be returning the skyline or not
  • 11 1
 I've had my last camelback coming up 10 years next year and I've just tried the leatt one, I've gone straight back to old trusty. It simply can't be beaten.
  • 3 1
 Ive tried out several packs, from cheep up to the expensive....ish! I keep going back to Camelbak, the charge LR, its about 5 years old now and still going strong. Only thing is in the heat of a good summer I wish it was a 3ltr bladder not 2, so I may give a skyline LR a go!!
  • 2 3
 The old ones have BPA so I'm told. I stopped using my old one for this reason. Old being 10 years as well..
  • 10 0
 @atrokz: you can buy a new bladder and stuff it into your old bag if that's a concern
  • 1 0
 @speed10: At this point, I'll just get a new pack. The bladders aren't too expensive but they aren't an exact fit and the new bags sit nicer and are more ergonomic. Good point though.
  • 8 1
 @atrokz: any BPA that was going to leach into your water would have done so long ago, and isn't an issue 10 years in. Also, if you've ever eaten anything out of a can, you've been exposed to more BPA than your Camelback would ever leach out.

As much as I'm all for reducing unnecessary chemicals like BPA in our everyday products, if you have an old water bottle/camelback don't throw it out for this reason. The science on BPA is sound, it is not good for you to ingest, but there is a certain amount of marketing at play here too, so be sure to read between the lines.
  • 4 5
 @acrossthec: Do you have evidence that supports that BPA only affects plastics for a certain amount of time then isn't an issue? That doesn't seem to be the case from everything online, but camelback stopped using BPAs in their hard plastic bottles since 2008 so prob not an issue for most people anyway.

Yea I started avoiding certain canned goods for that reason, esp tomatoes where the acid pulls the chemicals from the lining.
  • 10 1
 Still have my trusty Camelbak H.A.W.G. I've been using since 2003. Y'all are debating BPA and I'm over here trying to think if I have cleaned out my reservoir other than after that one time I put like 80 oz of beer in it at a party 7 years ago.
  • 1 0
 @nvonf: lad!!!

yeah I changed my bladder, but to be fair never washed it, just use often and continually rinse it out. Job done!!!!!
  • 1 0
 I still have my military issue MULE from 2000, it's been everywhere with me, mountain bike rides in the Alps, three GNCC cross country races, three seasons of harescrambles. When it wasn't on a mountain bike ride it was carrying water for me for everything else that I have done that required carrying liquid. I literally am so attached to it every time I go look at the new ones I'm incapable of buying one. It's zip tied together in some spots, and I think I'm on bladder number 6 or 7 but it still does it's job after countless crashes, wad ups, and ridiculous tumbles. I don't think I'll replace it until it disintegrates.
  • 13 6
 water bottle & fanny pack.
  • 5 2
 Or better yet the new dakine fanny pack with a hydration system. Works great!
  • 73 1
 or fill a procore with water
  • 2 3
 @jaycubzz: comment of the year ahahaha
  • 1 0
 Been running the raceface ambush for few weeks and its great alt to packs. Tired of my old wingnut floppin around. These new lowriders look good for rides longer than 2 h20 bottles etc.
  • 2 0
 Any suggestions on how to lash a FF helmet to the built-in strap hooks on Skyline? My MULE NV's dual-clip bulk-carry pocket was perfect for strapping down a FF for the climbs, but it appears that a more creative solution is needed to accomplish the same on the Skyline. The Skyline has been great so far, the lack of an obvious FF carry solution is pretty much my only complaint.
  • 11 5
 I guess this will be popular with the hipsters
  • 15 0
 IF> pun intended

THEN positive props + Smile - made me laugh

ELSE negative props + Frown - hipsters have feelings too man

/IF>

WTF we have emoticons? Big Grin
  • 8 2
 I'm guessing it will be way more popular with the backsters. Smile
  • 11 6
 Osprey Raptor 14. Enough said. Plus it comes in the color black and not the color 7th grade.
  • 2 0
 Have you used one of the Camelbak LR packs before? They're in a different league in terms of stability, the only packs I could DJ in and forget they're there.
  • 7 1
 but I always take the kitchen sink !
  • 2 0
 I had a Raptor and loved it initially until I realized just how tight things were having to get to secure the pack. This was causing pressure across my shoulders and even breathing was difficult at times, unable to fully expand lungs - big problem with asthma. This design really makes a difference!
  • 1 0
 I know the feeling. I have that with my evoc pack. I have to wear stuff semi loose during climbs.
  • 6 0
 Does it come in not-ugly?
  • 4 0
 I had no idea the handle on the bladder is meant to fit into that slot on my Camelbak
  • 1 0
 There is a hook and loop attachment above that one as well.
  • 5 1
 I really like the magnetic holder. I let my hose fall and it locks right into place!
  • 2 0
 The idea of lower weight is really great, I like it and was considering this one for a while but finally due to low storage capacity and MAINLY now spin protection in upper part bought evoc stage ..
  • 1 0
 These packs are great, I tried camelbak, osprey, vaude, Dakine, and deuter. I bought each bag and tried it for months and in the end this new low ride camelbak was overall the best.(the one I ended up with is the first generation of this bag being reviewed) I still have a camelbak that is over 10 years old that has been used as my off road moto pack for 10 years now. Camelbaks are the best in my book. Keep on innovating camelbak!
  • 1 0
 Still use my seven year old camel back and I find the water is stored low because I just buy a bottle of water and stick that in it. Stopped using the bladder a long time ago. Should maybe get a replacement but it's not a problem
  • 5 1
 The water already sits low in my pack, because.....err...its water. Heavier than air. :-P
  • 1 0
 I just ordered this pack since it's on sale at REI. I've got two Camelbaks (MULE and Lobo) and they've both been great, but something lower on the body sounds good plus the Lobo does quite have the space I need and the Mule is too big for riding in the summer unless I absolutely need to take a lot of stuff with me.
  • 1 0
 Think I may have to pick one of these up. My Osprey pack is a little too large and a little too loose for rides, not to mention when the going gets steep, I usually end up with the pack around my neck :/

Really like my Mule from back in the day, but with no partition for ventilation, it was a killer in the summer
  • 1 0
 Just one of several cool, innovative ideas from Camelbak in the last few years. Too bad colors and aesthetics in general are piss poor across their line. Platypus, Dakine and Osprey are all making much better looking products.
  • 5 3
 Lost me at "Low-slung, ultra-comfortable option designed for technilcal trail riders." For when things just aren't technical they're TECHNICAL!!!!
  • 1 1
 You guys should try Source Hipster Hydration Belt if you haven't. I just got mine not long ago, and went on a couple of rides already. The one thing that stood out for me was the comfort of the pack.????
  • 2 0
 Source has one of the worst water flow rates out of any of the hydration reservoir companies...allows the user less than half of what the CamelBak reservoir puts out per sip.
  • 1 0
 I got this bacause i hate the feeling of the pack coming over my head when i fluff a jump......nice and stable now or my skills have got better Wink
  • 4 0
 wingnut
  • 3 0
 Thanks for turning me on to Wingnut Packs! Very nice and handbuilt in the USA!
  • 3 0
 Bonus: Hip straps keep the love handles in check.
  • 3 0
 "the Hoover" of hydration packs? Dam, vacuum or J. Edgar?
  • 2 0
 USWE. Try it or you're missing out.
  • 2 0
 I like the idea of keeping the weight lower on the body.
  • 1 0
 I love mine. It fits great with a neck brace too for those looking for a smaller bag for doing downhill.
  • 1 0
 Still rockin the camelback rocket from 1998. Maybe time for an upgrade.
  • 1 0
 Right when I started shopping for hydration packs! Perfect timing haha
  • 1 0
 first time I have seen it. looks like it could be worth a try thanks
  • 1 0
 USWE. Once you try one you won't go back.
  • 1 0
 i'd really like to try one. I am using the SWAT vest and bibs now, with great success, but the water capacity is limited. With a bottle on the bike, and two small 1/2 liter bottles in the bibs, I can get about 1.8 liters. But that leaves only one pocket for gear.

The Airborne 9 looks to be the one, got any experience with it?
  • 1 0
 @blast-off: I have the F3 Pro. Stays in one place, doesn't bounce, and very hard to notice its there.
  • 2 1
 Every single product I've had from Camelbak leaks. Never again.
  • 2 0
 I wonder if they've done anything to tighten up the tolerances between the bladder and top cap to stop it leaking there, or if the bite valve has improved at all. Both places leaked on two previous camelbaks. And it wasn't just a little bit, but a constant drip from the valve and a puddle in my car from the screw top. So annoying! I originally bought it to wear skiing but that was an absolute no-go...freezing temps and being covered in water? NOPE
  • 1 0
 I've only had leak of the three packs I owned. The mouth piece finally started leaking after about a year of use
  • 2 3
 Race Face Stash Tank Top... is the best!!!

www.pinkbike.com/photo/11931626

Beer
  • 5 3
 hmm, i do not want to crash on my back with a pump and giant water bottle crushing my spine.
  • 3 0
 @aresiusbe: true story........ My camelback has actually helped prevent back injury during a nasty crash and roll
  • 1 0
 @JC9won4: I see your individual points but remember, RF designed the stash thinking of things like portability, ease of use, practicality... etc. If they wanted to design something to protect your back, they would have. And also, I'm pretty sure Camelback does the same.

I like to ride thinking about having fun, not crashing!!! Beer
  • 1 1
 @smoranc: Indeed, during the ride my focus is also on the fun part. Bad karma if you do not!
  • 1 1
 Mmmmmmm......... putting all the weight on the lower back !
  • 5 0
 but there is a pocket for Advil.
  • 2 0
 It puts it around your hips like a belt, it takes a ton of stress off your back and lower neck.
  • 1 0
 ULTRAMAN.
Below threshold threads are hidden







Copyright © 2000 - 2024. Pinkbike.com. All rights reserved.
dv65 0.076682
Mobile Version of Website