The only real reason to spend more on a drivetrain these days is to get maximum range. While XT is no shrinking violet on that score (it’s now also offered with an 11-46 tooth cassette option), SRAM’s 10-50 tooth Eagle groups are the undisputed kings of gear range.
But when it comes to bang for your buck? You can’t beat XT. It’s a hell of a value and that’s why it’s our winner for 2016. Every editor on staff has ridden the piss out of this stuff and we are, to a rider, impressed by what Osaka achieved with this group. Shimano was years late to the one-by game, but they delivered big with this group.
Aftermarket cassettes will kick their as, don't worry...
Destroyed one with a small tree branch, broke in the cage, and also broke in the main body which is guess what plastic!
Picked up an SLX 11speed and the difference is chaotic in terms of durability. Yes it's heavier (50grams) but it's worth it.
The main body is metal instead of plastic, and the cage is a lot stronger due to different metals probably.
The XT cage can be bent with slight pressure where the SLX needs 10times the force to bent it.
If you are not a totaly weight weenie and need a piece of mind go SLX RD.
I guess you were unlucky too, but XT and SLX are, IMO, miles apart. In the same vein if you're that concerned then why bother with SLX at all, just go with Deore. But I guess we all have a level to which we feel it will affect both ours and the bikes performance.
If we admit it, 99% of us on this forum don't need anything more than Deore but we still go and buy XT, XTR, Saint etc. because above all the gloss and marketing, when you use it you realise it just works.
I can honestly say I've never had a better pairing than that of an XT shifter and a Saint RD. And so I replaced my Saint mech with another. Yeah, I run the risk of the same thing happening again, hurting my wallet, but that's the price I'm willing to pay as the last time I used a Zee mech it just didn't 'feel' right.
I have a GX/NX mix on my bike and sure the lever is a little plastic-ey but it shifts flawlessly.
For me personally, I've ridden bikes with parts all over the map, and when stuff is adjusted well, it all works nicely, but when you own the bike and ride it day after day, the differences really do become apparent, primarily in shifters, which really are the heart of your drivetrain because they control everything. NX is fine, and it works, but if you ride it compared with X1 or X01 there is a distinct feeling of "it doesn't work as well as it could be". So if you're someone who is used to high tier stuff, and you drop down to low-mid tier stuff, the difference is gigantic and all the little quirks become more apparent to you as a rider.
But in all honesty, for dependable, workhorse compoments that will do everything you want day in and day out and not complain, mid -> mid-high level is where you want to aim. XT/SLX, X1 or X1/GX. Putting it all back into perspective, all you really "need" to ride your bike is an SS setup, tires, and no suspension. EVERYTHING else is just a bonus.
That said I went from an X01 setup on the trail bike to a XT 11spd setup (well just derailleur/shifter, I kept the SRAM cassette) and it's pretty good.
Nice suspension and light/strong wheels is where the money saved can be spent.
Disconnect your shock and then cycle the suspension with and without the clutch on.
Having said that my favorite shifter/der combo is 10sp X0/X9 type 2. The best shifter rear mech feel of all times, in my books, goes to 9sp X0 sfiter/der combo. That thing was crispy and brutal. Kling klang klong! Loved it!
And if you ever want to get whiplash, think about how crappy drivetrains were only about a decade ago in comparison to what we have now. I'm sure there'll be a bunch of gearbox agitators on this thread - but the steady evolution and refinement of the standard drivetrain is pretty stunning.
*When being sold by Chain Reaction below local bike shop COST, not even allowing them to be close to competitive...
Kinda glad those days are gone.
In fact, I paid $299 in July when I bought the groupset for my bike. The only thing lacking is the bottom bracket, which I paid $19 for. If you're building a bike, there is no better deal to be had.
Maybe because shimano pays the bills?
Join Pinkbike Login