Giant USA Jump on the Direct Sales Bandwagon

Feb 12, 2016 at 5:56
by Pinkbike Staff  
Bicycle Retailer and Industry News today reported that Giant USA's general Manager John Thompson announced to dealers that it will sell bicycles direct to consumers who will collect their purchases at a Giant store.

"Giant Gear also will be sold online under a similar system, except the products will be drop-shipped directly to customers and Giant will handle returns without involving dealers. The local store will get 100 percent of the regular margin on the accessory purchase if they stock the product and 80 percent if they don’t.

"Giant USA is rolling out a beta version of its program in March with a small group of Giant Retail Partner Stores. The company will use a platform provided by SmartEtailing. “Once we’ve refined our tools and processes, by August we plan to implement our omnichannel strategy to the entire U.S. market,” Thompson said in email sent to Giant dealers." - BRAIN


Trance

Will you be making your next purchase online?



The article then goes on to explain how the financial breakdown will affect dealers.

An outline of the program would give dealers 100 percent margin on the advertised retail price (ARP) ordered online through the Giant USA website to those dealers who normally stock the bikes that are ordered less a 2.5 percent credit card fee and any financing costs.

Dealers who have not stocked the ordered bikes in the last 12 months will receive 80 percent of the margin on the advertised retail price. Dealers would also absorb freight costs, the same as if the dealer were special ordering the bike. The dealer can combine the bike shipment with other orders to reduce freight costs.

And dealers who sell a bike online through their own Giant supported website will get the full ARP margin regardless of whether the dealer has stocked that particular series of bikes. And only Giant Race Series Retailers will be eligible to deliver orders of Giant’s top-level race models. Giant dealers will also receive credit for sales every 48 hours."
- BRAIN

John Tompson closes with the following statement:

“The way consumers buy bikes and gear is rapidly advancing and we want our retailers to win as the environment transforms here in the U.S.,” he said. “Our Giant Web Link is 100 percent committed to helping you grow your retail store’s revenue, profits and business relevance.” - BRAIN

Originally reported by Marc Sani - BRAIN.


MENTIONS: @GiantBicycle



Author Info:
pinkbikeaudience avatar

Member since Jul 22, 2013
3,465 articles

168 Comments
  • 123 3
 Problem here is that it just gives a brand loyal customer a chance to buy a bike they really want without having to special order it at a LBS who may try to steer them toward a stock item. However, it doesn't change the pricing which is why the recent German "upstarts" like YT and Canyon have surged to be well established at this point, and will only continue to grow if the price disparity remains. As long as YTs pricing on the top spec Carbon Tues Pro remains at US $5500 while companies like Giant are selling their top spec Glory Advanced at $8500 with lesser component spec, Giant will continue to lose huge market segment to true Internet Direct to Consumer companies.
  • 50 4
 Exactly- why order online if I still have to go to the shop? Any bike I have purchased at a LBS, I've been able to negotiate a decent discount, with the online system that goes away.
  • 53 1
 Amen. Who cares if prices for the consumer don't drop?
  • 10 4
 They did bump the price up this year to 6300 for the top spec. However it does now have carbon cranks and wheels and they upgraded to fox float suspension front and rear. Pretty amazing spec for 6300.
  • 26 5
 The last big brand bike I bought at a LBS I got a discount of 630$ off from MSRP ($2630 down to $2000), why would I ever choose to pay full price knowing deals can be made at an LBS and why would I ever choose to buy a big brand bike when I can get a YT bike for way less! This article read to me as "LOOK NOW YOU CAN PAY EVEN MORE FOR A BIG BRAND BIKE"
  • 3 1
 That is a good point and from my perspective it seems like going into the shop to buy the bike they would likely give you 10 to 15% off of any bike they have in stock already because they could possibly take a 20% hit right off the bat if you ordered online. Obviously this does not cover situations where they don't have the specific bike you have but it's good to note.
  • 6 4
 Yeah, its not really direct at all. Buying an in-stock item from the lbs is more direct than ordering, waiting, and then picking it up from the store. The only upside is no shipping cost to buyer.
  • 7 0
 I see what they are trying to do by trying to broaden up their customer base....but it seems, to me at least, they are chasing a working business model by using the wrong tactics. YT is crushing it because they are offering value for consumers dollar. I believe the margins are there for them to offer much lower prices and still pay their dealers.... Glad to see YT doing their thing and hope the big boys look at their pricing a bit closer.
  • 8 3
 I hate my previous giant LBS. I hate they'll still make money if i buy it online. Between those guys and od2, giant is dead to me
  • 7 0
 Leaves me perplexed. Perhaps its to get the infrastructure dialed before ultimately cutting out the shop? I don't understand it either. There are plenty who need the shop, so I get that part. Plenty who don't so what appeal will paying thousands more have?
  • 2 1
 This half way house never benefits myself, being cash customer I get discounts making big brands almost equal to YT/canyon
  • 4 0
 Yeah exactly, it looks like a toe in the water whilst they see what the German brands can do this year. If YT and Canyon kill it, then at least they can react quickly to cut out the lbs and sell direct , as infrastructure is in place. Surprised to see that Trek and Spesh havnt done this yet. I rekkon 2017 will be the year they all do.
  • 5 1
 Nowhere does Giant say they are going online shopping to compete with online-only competitors. They're just adding the "shop in your underwear" option. A fair number of retailers in general have online shopping now that still involves their brick&mortar store. It can work. Cash in hand at the LBS works for me.
  • 3 2
 Online prices don't reflect customer loyalty discounts. Folk above are right - noone ever pays 100% MSRP. Stick with your local Giant dealer. I will.
  • 5 0
 That's great if you have a local shop that deals. My local doesn't deal until the bike is at least a year old...and even then it's not a great deal. I'd buy online just to spite them
  • 7 7
 @warehouse
Why spite them? They're pricing their bike at the fair market value of that bike. The only time a shop should have to discount a bike is when it's undesirable, i.e. more than a year old. You as a customer are not entitled to a deal, a discount, or anything other than good service and polite sales staff. Badgering your local shop to sell to you at a loss is one way to ensure that year of free service can never be redeemed. I pity the shopkeep who is giving $630 off a $2500 bike. His job is pretty much gone.
  • 7 0
 I keep reading about discounts people on pink bike are getting from their lbs. makes me feel like I'm getting burned paying MSRP
  • 8 1
 @warehouse
It's pretty consistent across the industry that shops get a 35-40% margin on new bikes. The cost of doing business for an average sized shop (lights, rent, insurance, wages) is right around the 32% mark. At full retail the shop is bringing in 3-8% profit on $2600. That's $78-$208.

It's also a common misconception that the winter is the best time to buy a bike. In the winter many shops are struggling to stay afloat and losing money on a bike they can sell for more next summer is not an attractive option.

I much prefer to price my bikes fairly, and allow customers to earn the right to discounts through our loyalty program. This has allowed us to be competitive on price matching online retailers and ensures that the customers that enable us to survive the winter get the deals they deserve.

PS: As a Canadian your prices are only going to keep going up, every company has released 10-20% mandated price increases. Just a heads up.
  • 5 1
 Direct sales will continue to take revenue from standard bikes shops, leading to less money locally to hire new kids/teenagers coming up in the sport. Without bike shop discounts and connections most young talent simply will not develop to become better riders.
  • 1 3
 Check out Summit Cyclery in Holladay. New shop opens in two weeks and they're a Giant dealer.
  • 4 1
 @allix2456 Why should he get full MSRP? I'm not one of those that hates my LBS.

I've actually gone into more than one shop and had very frank discussion with the owners.
I’ll flat out tell him, I prefer to support a small local business however; I'm not rich, so I won’t pay MSRP from him when I can save going online. If he is ok with it, I’ll tell him the internet price and if they come close, I’ll order through them. It’s their choice.
Every shop I’ve done this with except one has agreed. Better to make 10-15% on a sale vs. losing the sale. Keep in mind, I have to pay tax buying from them as well.
I got $500 off my 2012 Stumpjumper, I bought a ton of parts from them and ended up buying my Tallboy carbon from them as well. As the shop started growing, the owner wasn’t around as much and so I couldn’t talk about the discount, so I stopped shopping there and went online.
I’ve since bought two new frames, Fox 36 and Fox 34 two set of wheels and a lot more. Do you think if I added up how much a spent and asked that owner if he would rather have a percentage of that money vs. nothing what do you think he’d say?
Business is adapt or die.
  • 2 1
 I've moved on to better things
  • 5 0
 I agree about loyalty programs.

My current LBS gives me 10-20% off msrp on anything, including specialized tires. Why wouldn't i buy everything from them when they're at or close to online price?

I've sent quite a few people their way and they take care of me. It's a win win.

Things like shimano parts they'll tell me to get it online because it's cheaper and they can't even buy shimano through their channels at a price that makes sense to resell it.

Honesty like that means a hell of a lot to me
  • 3 0
 I use a great LBS and can get what I want with a discount. I don't see a good bike shop as just a middle man who doesn't add any value.
Last spring I ordered a Reign, it took just a few days to arrive, and I got around $500 off. I picked it up ready to ride. The Reign was in high demand and I was lucky they had my size in stock.
I don't spend a ton of money there compared to the roadies, but the owner has recognized my loyalty and treats me well.
My friend bought a YT, and he'll be waiting at least a couple months for it. We hope it'll arrive in time for a planned trip to Moab in March...
  • 2 2
 I broke a giant, cracked the seat stay. Dropped it off at my LBS hoping to get a discount on a new one.(it was worked hard)
5 days later my new frame showed up, free. They warranted it. I don't think this would happen with a online retailer. I suspect my LBS's buying power had something to do with it.
  • 4 2
 It's hilarious how almost everyone commenting on this thread doesn't understand what direct to consumer means for pricing, or how maintaining sales through the IBD while implementing direct to consumer outreach requires prices to remain the same. Everyone on here comments about the price, because as a consumer, that is all they care about. In order for the local bike shop to carry these bikes, it requires the bike shop to make money. So while all of you blame Giant for not lowering pricing, what you are asking is to remove a giant revenue stream for bike shops. Like half of America, you buy from Wal-Mart and Amazon, and then bitch when there are no jobs for you.
  • 2 0
 allix2456, I doubt you have any influence on the pricing in your store and Westwood Cycle is hardly considered by anyone to be a shop to find good deals even with your price match policy I bought a Norco Range from DB for 1000.00 less in August of its model year than it was at WWC. They refused, not surprisingly to match DBs price even though both stores had the bike in stock. I can't see Glen and Kelly supporting their major brands going direct. Will be interesting to see how it plays out because there will always be better direct deals. The more consumers realize most bikes are more alike than not and that most come from the same handful of factories why would you pay more for any name over another?
  • 28 0
 Feels like they did this just so they can say they're hip with the times.

You order online, it goes to the shop, you have go to go the shop to get it. The price hasn't changed. So the only thing that's new is we can shop in our underware? Cool, I guess. Won't put a dent in YT or Canyon though.
  • 6 2
 Trek has similar program.
  • 16 1
 I'm aware, and it's similarly pointless. It's just a matter of "keeping up with the Jones" at this point.
  • 5 1
 I hate to be the one to say it, but anyone with decent mechanical skills, a proper set of tools, and an internet connection really doesn't need a LBS anymore.
  • 4 1
 Without my LBS, I wouldn't have learned decent mechanical skills, or known what tools to buy so I can service my own bikes. YouTube videos and manuals only go so far, being physically shown the correct method to fix/adjust/fit something by a mechanic is priceless.
  • 1 0
 I learned as I go. Did somethings wrong and probably still do. But the youtubes, manuals and forums helped out immensely.
  • 3 1
 More like YT hasn't put a dent in Giant, Specialized, or Trek sales. YT is a hot topic and buzz word, but they do in a year with most these companies do in month — maybe even in a week.
  • 1 0
 @CollieLaxer Well, keep in mind, Amazon really didn't put much of a dent into the numbers of big box stores for the first few years it was around, too. Yeah, there's always going to be people who will visit a LBS because they need to be told what they should be riding, and don't have the intelligence, inclination or time to work on their bikes themselves, but for those of us who know what they're looking for, and don't see the point of a LBS anymore, it's really, really nice to be able to have that choice, and be rewarded with more bike for the dollar.
  • 1 0
 @CollieLaxer amen to that. YT is peanuts compared to giant, trek, specialized.
  • 26 1
 This won't matter. Direct to consumer sales is really an advantage for one reason: lower prices. If you keep greasing the LBS in the process, prices stay high and guys like YT will still crush you.
  • 6 0
 I agree completely. However, YT is only a threat in a very small albeit growing market. Brands like Canyon with a full line-up pose a far greater threat. They have competitive bikes across all disciplines. There's also a company called Fazzari who seems to be picking up momentum with a full-suite. However, they lack the credibility that can be earned through sponsoring a race-team and terrible name. The times they are a-changin'!
  • 1 0
 I see your point. But right now, the company doesn't sell to the LBS. They sell to a distributor, that then sells to the LBS. So if they can take out the national distributors, prices would drop. Though that would also mean, that they can't outsource their storage/shipping in the same way they have. Which for a large company like Giant, would be rather tough.
  • 4 1
 YT isn't really crushing anyone. They can't keep up with demand.

If someone had a good bike at YT like prices with product in stock, then they'd crush it with enthusiast bike purchases.

I'd bet a super low percentage of LBS sales is upper middle to high end builds. Most of the bikes i see sold when I'm there are cruiser/ commuter/$500 hardtails
  • 1 0
 @utahbikemike that depends on the shop. The cheapest bike my bike shop sells is $2k. Every-time I go in there someone is buying an expensive bike. They've developed a niche for only trail-worthy mountain bikes and parts by actually carrying an inventory of everything.
  • 3 0
 I'm not saying those bikes dont get sold. Im just saying they're a small amount in the grand scheme of things.
  • 1 0
 Also, a 2k bike now a days is a carbon road bike with 105 componets, a high end hardtail or an entry level FS. Hardly high end, but it's a decent value price point
  • 18 0
 'Online Sales' might be a better description. 'Direct Sales' for a bike manufacturer implies removing the intermediary in order to lower cost to the consumer, which is not what Giant and Trek are doing. This is interesting but not.
  • 24 8
 No benefit to the consumer so f*ck Giant. Don't blindly support your "LBS".
Support your ILBS. Theres LBS and ILBS (independent local bike shops). Specialized stores, Trek, Giant, are are not Local, they are part of huge multinational corporations; posing as LBS and franchised by suckers.
Theres real LBS's out there who still stock quality bikes from smaller, better companies, I prefer to support them.
  • 3 1
 TRUTH!!!
  • 10 2
 Not quite true. My LBS is an independent, locally owned store that just happens to stock Giant. There are two Giant-owned stores in Australia but that's it. I'll be sticking with my mates.
  • 1 1
 Same as @iamamodel here. Our Giant LBS also stocks Trek, so I really doubt is part of an evil transnational corporation. Shop owner is a local, an avid rider and just good bloke. Giants are tough to beat on value (at least in Australia) unless you go online, which has its own inconvenients.
  • 3 7
flag SteveDekker (Feb 13, 2016 at 5:27) (Below Threshold)
 No offense, EL, An Kunt. But we don't care what bike shops do in Australia or Mexico. Good luck.
  • 5 1
 Never understood why riders these days dont want to support their LBS and when did this industry become a used car lot. Because they have to pay full retail? What makes us as consumers so entitled to a discount by just walking into shop? If you put up $2000 only to make $700 after shipping and time spent building and fitting that's not asking for much. The dialed LBSs offer incentives if you purchase a new bike from them like fitting, setting sag, priority in repairs, a service the web can't provide. Some folks have had a bad experience in their LBS but for the majority the LBS is a guy or gal or more folks, owning a small business, involved in their local cycling scene, advocating trails, offering free maintenance classes, organizing rides, and just wanting to make a living and live a nice lifestyle. And usually the LBS is the center of the cycling community so stopping in hanging, seeing what's new in stock, having a beer or you can jjust sit in your underwear in front of the computer.

Most areas the market needs an LBS that offers the big companies like tthat offer a full range of bikes. That's not a bad thing because just a small % of cycling is smaller companies like YT and Ibis only offering a few bikes. Times are changing and we will see a lot of bike shops close in the years coming because of a handful of reasons and those who will stay open will most likely be the big guys in populated urban areas and the small, owner operated shop.
  • 2 2
 @Stevedekker, I used to live in California. My LBS there was independently owned and stocked Giant and other brands. And the other two Giant dealers in the area were also independent. No offence but you are wrong to say "f*ck Giant" and "support your ILBS" in the same breath.
  • 1 1
 I work at a shop that sells Specialized and is locally owned. Not sure what you mean here but we all ride and take care of our customers and friends, none of us are evil suits. As @Schwaby said, we provide a lot of incentives for people who purchase our bikes.
  • 1 1
 @SteveDekker
You really are quite off base. A friend of mine owns a small shop that stocks Giant, but also Kona, Bianchi, Breezer, and Volagi. I work for a shop that sells Specialized, and Raleigh, Redline, Haro, Felt..... Blah blah blah. Point is we only servive because of our customer service. We aren't franchised. We aren't corporate monkeys posing as locals. With the way the industry is, specialized (or other big companies for that matter) work for us. If shops don't sell bikes made by Specialized, specialized doesn't sell bikes.
  • 1 0
 @Schwaby: nothing wrong with supporting your local LBS, however their is nothing wrong with purchasing online from a consumer direct model. We have choices and that is a good thing
  • 15 0
 If this makes Giants cheaper, I would explore them at my next purchase. If the cost stays the same, this is a waste of time for consumers.
  • 3 1
 Giant are already priced reasonably for how well they spec their bikes. Having said that, I bought my 2016 Giant Reign Advanced 1 for $4700AUD (RRP $5600AUD) which only happened because of the relationship between the LBS and myself. Unless those kind of discounts exist online, this model is not at all useful for the consumer. Disappointing.
  • 17 1
 "Blah blah blah prices still ridiculous blah blah blah" - Giant
  • 12 1
 Big bike companies are feeling the squeeze from the European bike market . bikes in the USA are to expensive
  • 7 0
 I agree with everyone who thinks this new system won't change a thing, and likely eliminate any potential deal from negotiating with a dealer. The biggest advantage I see with a LBS when it comes to sales (ignoring post sales issues) is the ability to go there and actually sit on a bike. Giant and Trek and any other manufacturers following this business model need to capitalize on this fact.

I'd like to see Giant keep a database of what bikes are available on the showroom floor of all their retailers. This way I don't have to phone around to every retailer within a 2 hour drive to find the bike I want in the correct size just to sit on it for a minute and see if I like how it feels.

Manufacturers should also support the test ride philosophy by making it easier for bike shops to keep more bikes on the show room floor and to make them readily available for a proper test ride. Many shops will rent bikes, and then deduct the rental fee from a purchase. However if I want to try multiple brands from different shops, the cost adds up quickly, and rental fees other than at the shop I finally make my purchase are not recoverable. I shouldn't have to wait until Crankworks comes to Whistler in August to test a high performance bike because no bike shops can afford to stock it. Besides I wanted to buy it before the season started, not near the end.
  • 11 2
 I love the idea that bike shops have some Galactic Right To Exist No Matter What. It's adorbz.
  • 5 4
 I love how uninformed kids assume they're entitled to a discount on the latest and greatest in demand item. If you can't afford it, buy a bike you can.
  • 3 1
 That's awesome because it actually makes sense. Don't buy beyond your means. Words to live by but very few follow.
  • 7 0
 @allix2456 I'm not a kid and no I'm not entitled to a discount, but I am entitled to choice. I'm entitled to buy from whomever gives me the best price. You remind of my local LBS, the closest one to me. Won't deal at all everything is MRSP. I think I've gone there once in a pinch for some .95 cent part I had to pay $4 for.

You seem to think you're entitled to more money from me just because.
  • 3 0
 I'm not entitled to anything! Especially your money. What you do with it is your business. I like discount's just like everybody else because I'm not a superstar sponsored athlete. So If a LBS isn't willing to budge on a price. Life goes on. Find what your looking for elsewhere. Cheers
  • 2 0
 We're all guilty,

"Giant" bike manufactures monopolizing the industry.
Smaller bike companies having to go manufacture in Asia to compete
Smaller bike companies having to utilize online retailers to compete with the "Giant" bike manufactures.
"Giant" bike manufactures controlling LBS and now selling online to keep smaller bike companies from competing.
Consumers buying way too much stuff from large on-line dealers and eBay for rock bottom pricing.


Greed!!! Greed!! Greed!! Everyone is f'ing over their own countries!!! From top to bottom!!! Screw Giant!!! Manufacture Local!! Buy local and think small!! Create local jobs, support LBS, Sale it at a reasonable price. Bike Shops stop thinking your entitled and earn your customers!!!


This pc of garbage JT who works for Giant and used to work for Specialized needs his ass whipped!!! People like him are destroying the industry and in my case America!!
  • 1 0
 Agreed.... Support your local bike stores. You can always find a great deal if your patient enough. Plus face to face contact is way better than electronic commomunication any day. I'm old fashion that way in which I like to be able to touch what I'm buying. Plus it Stimulates the local economy and creats jobs. Sad that the big 3 giant bike manufacturers are like the OPEC of the bike industry. Unlike the Oil industry, there is a lot more options out there when it comes to who you want to support when purchasing your new two wheel steed. Unfortunately, you will never destroy the industry because you got retards like myself who throw thousands of dollars a year into this sport I love dearly and will probably do so until I stop breathing.
  • 5 0
 Interesting though we feel our "true" direct-to-consumer model is what many people want. Buying online is not for everyone of course and there is still a place for the LBS for many. Then there are those who know what they want and are comfortable wrenching their own bikes and they will happily get a bit more bang-for-their buck by going direct. Especially here in Canada.

To fill that niche we are launching our brand new direct-to-consumer brand in a few short months. Here is our first model: www.pinkbike.com/photo/13162792
  • 1 0
 Looks awesome!
  • 6 1
 LBS's would P I S S E D if Giant went direct to consumer at a discount pricing.

As an OEM you dont spend years...no, decades(in the case of Giant)...building up a huge dealer network, just to turn around one day and stab them in the back and go discounted-direct to consumer via the web. That would be hugely unacceptable. There would be rioting in the streets.
You would cut off a revenue stream for your dealers (LBS's), making their business more difficult than it already is.
Dealers would drop the brand and not recommend that anyone purchase a Giant bike, it would hurt Giant.
People buying bikes online would not purchase all those highly profitable accessories that LBS's like to add to a bike purchase.
Do you really want to see your LBS close up shop? Think about it.

YT/Canyon/whoever can do it because they don't have a huge dealer network already established. They can price whatever they want and do not have to worry about adding margin for the dealers.

Personally, I don't really ever go to any LBS's. I do all my own work (except wheel builds) and buy my parts online for pennies on the dollar compared to brick-mortar store prices. But I don't want to see LBS's go away. So I am kind of a hypocrite, still trying to figure out a way to deal with that....

All that said, my next bike will probably be a YT
  • 3 1
 Give the shop a chance. My LBS matches most prices for parts that I find online.
  • 3 0
 Order your YT now for next season.
  • 2 0
 The good thing about that is you have time to consider if that's the bike you really want. For example, you probably won't have taken delivery until after they announce the 2017 model year bikes have Boost... So you can conveniently cancel your order and get the 2017 instead. And the same will happen the year after, thereby saving you a lot of money. You don't really need a capra after all. You want one but you don't need one.
  • 5 0
 To be honest, selling bikes at the shop is the least profitable part of the business, you get stuck with sizes and colours and before you know it your parting it out or blowing it out at cost. Shops survive because of the service, consumables and after-market parts. This will affect the big brand stores, but it wont affect the nook and cranny service shops.
  • 12 6
 Good to see that big bike manufacturers are keeping LSBs in the loop while trying to go to an online puchase system. Hopefully it will work in practice.
  • 2 2
 Agreed, the fact that the shops will still be making all their money should be a reassuring fact in theory unless there is some fine-print we're missing here.
  • 1 1
 This is good news. Expect others to follow...
  • 4 2
 It's no news. These brands sill won't be competitive with the sales model they're trying to copy. Unless I want a custom spec not available from a shop, this doesn't really change anything. Still have to go to the bike shop to get bike, why not get one that's already on the floor?

Unless this is leading to a menu-type ordering program where eventually bike shops will truly only be a middle man, where you cannot buy a bike from the floor, I don't see this how this is a step forward.
  • 4 0
 I think this is just the first step to cutting the LBS. Giant can't let down their distributors from one day to another. They need to do it gradually. The sales model is changing very fast, and the actual prices are insane. At the end, the LBS will be just assembling them and managing some sort of guarantees agreed before directly with the brands.
  • 4 3
 It actually seems like the only one having benefit from this concept is the lbs. They don't have to stock completes and risk not selling them. Giant will deliver the bikes and the lbs' full profit to the shop, so many new people will be introduced to these lbs'. They will probably have to assemble the bikes on the costs of the customer. And they don't have to waste time dealing with warranty issues, angry customers, etc, etc. No one is winning on this, except for the local bike shops.
  • 7 0
 I call bullshit... Supporting local bike shops at first until they are forced to sale only giant bikes.
  • 5 0
 Without joking, that is typically Specialized. Its how they force / trick shops into becoming their concept stores.
  • 5 0
 "Here newly established bike shop: place an order for 100 high end road bikes. Most of our shops sell much more than this! Just know that next year you'll have to order 101+ if you want to stay a Specialized retailer! Oh you're now horribly in debt? We'll forgive you if you hand over the keys to your company and work for us as an underpaid store manager!"

Aren't they a gem?
  • 6 1
 This is garbage news. Prices won't go down at all. And that is the whole point of direct consumer purchases. YT and Canyon own the biz right now. And they have really good bikes.
  • 4 0
 If one is in the retail you'll understand that Giant and Trek are trying to share the profit with their long time lbs partners, which is a very touching move but unfortunately it won't work if they can't find savings for the customers.
  • 3 0
 having worked in shops, seeing the small margins on bikes
it puzzles me how some " bike dealers" stay in biz.
online direct is a natural transition for most riders.
but shops do make a decent profit on accessories.
starting to see more smaller shops just selling tires,
accessories, apperal, & service.
  • 2 15
flag f00bar (Feb 12, 2016 at 9:07) (Below Threshold)
 Small margins my ass.
30% is pretty much the minimum. With high-end bikes, the margin is often around 50%.

No wonder Canyon can sell their own version of a €4000 Trek Remedy for €2500.
  • 7 0
 Margin is pretty much the same on all bikes. Sometimes it will actually lessen on the higher end models. The only time that you get margins that are around 50% is when it is a past year model that the bike company is trying to move.
  • 5 0
 30% is not much when you consider quite a big part of their stock won't get sold before the new line comes in, so they'll have to sell a big part again without profit or even losing money on it. Then you can deduct all the costs like the building, all the people who work there, electricity, advertising, etc. And from that tiny piece that's left, they'll have to deduct about half of it for taxes. So no, 30% margin is not much if you own a brick store and have people working for you. It is okay though if you have an online shop and stock everything in your garage and basement and do all the work yourself.
  • 2 9
flag jerryhazard (Feb 12, 2016 at 12:06) (Below Threshold)
 Small margins? Seriously? When a bike retails for nearly $10K, 30% is a LOT. Perhaps of margins were reduced, or if actual manufacturer cost were reduced, they'd sell MOAR bikes.
  • 3 1
 At the same time, you will have to invest several full time month salaries just to stock that one bike. It's a big risk and I've seen €5000 bikes for sale for only €2000 in lbs' because they couldnt get rid of it. In that case you even lost roughly €1500 on just that one bike.

You obviously have no clue how things go in reality. If it was that easy that you simply stock a $10.000 bike and its sold the next day, lbs' would be millionaires. But in reality they are going bankrupted one by one.
  • 2 0
 In reality, with a 30% margin, you'd need to sell roughly 5 or 6 bikes to be able to stock a new one (not even having profit yet because all your profit went into stocking that one new bike).

This is a theoretical example where all these bikes have the same value, just to show that even if you sell everything you have in your store, you won't make enough profit to use that on restocking everything again. You'll have to invest the biggest part again yourself to be able to restock everything you've sold.
  • 1 0
 So you sell everything in the store, and can't afford to restock? That is not a margin problem. Yes, that might be "how it works", but that doesn't make it "correct", and the root problem is not the margin. Like many things, something in the system is amiss. Playing along and whining about margin's isn't going to fix it.

The problem is the cost of the goods is too high. That needs to change.
  • 1 0
 And if a TREK store can sell half a dozen of THEIR dh bikes at nearly 50% off... the msrp of those products can indeed come down.
  • 3 0
 If they ship it to the shop, I have a big heavy unhandy box I will carry home my foot, since no way any bike shop will allow me to assemble it myself in their shop. Not a big fan of this system to be honest, it neither has the benefits of real direct sales like YT, nor the benefits of a lbs who can help people make tought decisions, wether it is on sizing, which model is best for local trails etc.
  • 3 0
 So once the system is up and running smoothly with many sales coming from the giant web site , what is to stop giant from changing the rules of the game and either lowering the profit margin to the lbs or completely cutting them out?
  • 3 0
 Say goodbye to the small town local bike shop. I have a buddy that has been selling Giant bikes for 20+ years. He's stuck with the brand through its ups and downs. This is how Giant repays its loyal retailers.
  • 4 1
 This can only help him. He does less work, takes less financial risk, and still gets paid.
  • 1 1
 There's a difference between a giant shop and a shop that sells giant! If anything this will create so many more headaches for those of us who work at giant shops. Pretty much no average customer knows their right size for a start.
  • 6 0
 Giant is a fuckin goober.
  • 8 0
 Thank you for inspiring me to increase my use of the word "goober"
  • 2 0
 " Giant is a f*ckin goober." quoted for eloquence. !
  • 2 0
 I don't know about everyone else, but here in SoKal, one thing there isn't a shortage of, is GIANT dealers.
I don't know if they provide the best margin or what, but it seems like I've got easily a half-dozen of FULL-STOCKING(or damn close to it) dealers within 15 mins of me.
Since I like to be able to have a place I can rely on to bring my $4-$6k bike to for any issues, the last thing I'm gonna do is pay full pop for a bike that I can't ride, or even see in person first, all the while possibly alienating a place a might very well need to warranty something for me in the future.
Especially when I can spend 10mins of my time driving to a store that will have said bike in stock, and give me a better deal than MSRP as well
  • 2 0
 I try to split my business. I try to do as much as I can through my LBS, but sometimes I need to find a way to cut cost. it's hard to justify going to my LBS when I can save 40% on an item. Unless I get sponsored, I don't see this changing.
  • 2 0
 Hang on. .......you can already go to any brands website, see what you like and then contact your nearest lbs holding that brand. If they don't have it in stock they can get it for you. .....so what is do revolutionary about this concept giant are talking about
  • 3 1
 The uncertainty of shopping online AND the inconvenience of having to visit the retail store anyway...all at msrp plus tax? Now that's the worst of both worlds...sounds like a real winning combination.
  • 4 0
 Dunno. I buy giants because my lbs does'nt charge me full retail. Maybe ill elsewhere now
  • 2 1
 Direct Sales Bandwagon? Tell me how you really feel about it pinkbike staff.

For everyone that doesn't feel like reading a page of fluff:

-Giant now will offer sell direct to users.
-Bike-shops still make money, but it is tiered differently.
-You still have to pick your bike up at a Giant retailer.
-Expect higher accessory mark ups.
  • 2 0
 Also, "Giant will handle returns without involving dealers" so you have to deal with it.
Are the bikes going to be built? Or is there a fee?
Whole thing sounds bogus. A way to prop up sales but no upside to the consumer, in fact sounds even more inconvenient.
And most shops wont be able to the good bikes anyway.
  • 1 0
 I wonder if bike shops should bother buying the bikes at all. Just wait till a buyer picks one out. All they need to provide is demos
  • 5 2
 Nobody will utilize the accessory add-ons when they have the computer at their finger tips and sites like Chain Reaction and Wiggle and Merlin just one click away.
  • 4 0
 competition is a bugger... thank god appeared the german new wave!! someone is goin to put down their trousers...
  • 1 0
 I think the idea has merit, often what drives overheads up is carrying tons of inventory. now a dealer can go deeper in some sku's and still get that rare xl TCR adv team sale or xl glory adv or whatever expensive model to a customer without so much risk. that is provided Giant stocks enough themselves. having 10 big dollar bikes as turkeys is tough on the bottom line.
  • 3 0
 So this offers advantages to everyone....except the customer. It seems to me like price control, nothing else. Crap idea, destined to fail.
  • 1 0
 leave it to the small companies to be smart enough to be customer direct, just to make ends meet…. now the big players are scared of this change and are willing to be called "bandwagon" companies!!!!
way to innovate! corporate "giants"
  • 1 0
 Motorcycle/Snowmobile dealers are around 5-10% margin and they make it. Most industries are having to operate at a lower margin - bike shops will have to follow.

12 years ago I sold Fly Racing gear. Motorcycle shops are happy to get 35pts but bike shops wouldn't even look at the gear unless they got 50pts!
  • 1 0
 the money has to come from somewhere. most retail business planning recommend 30% minimum AVERAGE margins. If your lower than that, something is probablly not being paid. many private shops own their buildings and because they don't have a mortgage they 'forget' to charge for the land/building.
  • 1 0
 Would the LBS have all models in store for test? Cause that would be the only potential benefit to the consumer I could relate to this "new" model - though highly unlikely.
Otherwise I see only Giant leaning out their supply chain and reduce working capital? Without passing on to consumer? All real B2C firms must be so happy about those dinosaurs, keeping the market price for bikes high up. This will allow yt, canyon, ... to do incremental up pricing of their range.. All good as long as they remain the cheaper alternative..
  • 1 0
 How does Yt sell so cheap? Seriously, they have technological wonders for frames and top end builds yet they sell so cheap. Where do they get the pull to do this? I would think r&d would take a big chunk of money. I must be jaded from the huge price tags from the big boys
  • 1 0
 It seems like an intermediate step towards a true direct sales system. Once they have the logistics running they cut out most of the bike shops and leave a reduced network of service centers (kinda similar to what Canyon has already), Giant will have one big advantage over the current direct sales players. They don't have to outsource the manufacturing. They own the factories. For all we know that could be where YT bikes are made.
  • 1 0
 I think people confuse expectation of discount with entitlement to discount. I don't walk into a shop feeling entitled to a discount by some act of god, but I expect to see prices lower than MSRP when I can literally go online and order it for significant discount. And when I say this, I mean things like last years products, which sit at MSRP in a shop and the same product in EVERY online retailer is sitting with a 30% discount. I don't necessarily expect price matching, but I expect shops to attempt to be competitive. If you come to me with the attitude of 'I'm an LBS and you should support us by paying MSRP without question' as though you're entitled to market share without staying competitive, then I'm not interested.
  • 3 0
 Some of this stuff kind of gets confusing. Can someone please explain? And I wonder if prices might go down?
  • 5 0
 Sounds like when someone purchases a bike directly from giant it is shipped to a dealer and assembled (with 80% of dealers margins) or if the dealer has it they get 100% of their margin and the customer can pick it up immediately. Pretty much sounds like giant is organizing sales for local bike shops. This is my understanding, sounds similar to the thing trek did a while ago, no clue how its working out
  • 1 0
 I would consider it if they allowed you to custom spec the build with all (or the majority) of components that you want then have that dropped to your LBS. That would be worth paying for.
  • 1 1
 I understand that the giant bikes are more or less good to go out of the box, Set up much better then the average industry bike in a box. I wonder how well set up these YT bikes, are brakes dialed in with no drag and gears set up properly? Just put on the seat, pedals and handlebars and go? A High end bike should take an LBS the better part of an hour to set up, who's setting up these YT's?
  • 2 1
 Um have you not been paying attention to the Cad dollar? You can't afford a new bike anyway, it would cost like a bazillion Cad.
  • 1 0
 bikes do not come set up in the box…. ask a bike shop….
  • 1 0
 nitronorth bring your bike over I'll set it up for a case of beer!
  • 1 0
 My YT was damn near built in the box. An idiot like me had it rolling in 30 mins a beer later.
  • 1 1
 This is long over due. While YT and such are out making bikes more affordable no companies have solved the riddle of bike maintenance. Giant is the first brand to attempt to bridge the gap of online vs in store sales that will really benefit both the customer and the LBS. Incredible job Giant and I wish you the best I just hope the numbers work out from a business standpoint. So we can move forward with this in the rest of the industry.
  • 1 1
 This is extremely interesting. One of the biggest in the world making a shift. They will go through growing pains and probably lose market share. In the long term, though, they are ahead of the curve. By them indicating a change in percentages for LBS they allow for a slow shift away from current standard practice. It will also probably take them a couple of seasons for pricing to come down to the area of other direct to consumer based brands. They need to do this slowly and step on as few toes as possible. The best transition phases are ones that aren't noticed until an entirely new way of doing things has been established. Smart.
  • 1 0
 Seriously how many people go to a shop and say I'll have THAT bike! Most riders I know go in and order the bike over the counter and spec it their preference. Isn't this just saving them a bit of hassle ??
  • 4 0
 indirect sales
  • 2 0
 Support your local bike shop. I drink beer with these guys on weekends. Beer
  • 1 0
 I saved 400$ in taxes buying my YT-USA. It may take a little longer for the .gov to fix that pothole, but I think we could do with 1 less F-35 and fix em all.
  • 3 3
 The shop I work at will be a beta store. It actually seems like a win for everyone. We will see how it goes as time rolls on.
  • 1 0
 I think its a plus for the shops. Good luck.
  • 2 0
 Except the customer.
  • 2 2
 How is it not good for the customer? They get what they want. its not our fault they don't want to come in to the store in the first place?
  • 1 1
 If people aren't buying Giants, it's got nothing to do with where/how they buy it and everything to do with the proper direct sales guys. If the big boys want to fight off the challenge of Canyon, YT etc then they need actual direct sales, with the price reduction to match.
If this results in less reduced Giants, it'll reduce sales not increase them. I own 3, and two were bought at substantial discount. I wouldn't have bought them otherwise.
  • 2 0
 So I go into my LBS to buy a set of wheels or a bike, they have to order, no stock at Giant. I go online to order, my order goes through and then I get a e-mail, no stock at Giant. While I was in the LBS they sold me something else. When I was online I went to CRC and bought, Now I go to CRC first. I don't see this as being good for my LBS to keep it's customers.
  • 1 3
 If this doesn't hurt the LBS, I'm down with it. More bike companies are seeing people buy bikes online. This will at least get them into a shop. Hopefully with a Big Brand like Giant, this will encourage more people to ride also. Plus hopefully not by Wally World Bikes. Get to know a shop, group rides, making friends. All the Benefits of being a Mountain Biker.
  • 1 0
 So just wait till mid/end of season and buy the bike you want on sale on Giants website? Ok, sounds good.
  • 1 0
 MTBs and parts are too pricey anyways. I mean brake discs and pads are cheaper for my car than for my bike, wait what?
  • 1 0
 Will you be making your next purchase online? Prob not, I don't think the milk man delivers yet.
  • 6 4
 Still no 29ers? Pass.
  • 4 0
 The Trance X 29er kinda sucked but I think they're missing sales by not releasing an updated Anthem 29er.
  • 2 1
 @f00bar, dude, 30% margin is shit, when you factor in overhead.
  • 1 0
 I work in the automotive aftermarket (racing and performance) and 30% is spot on for margin on most products in this industry.
  • 2 1
 on an $8 to $10 bicycle, it's not shit. No bike should cost that much. If margins are too small, get the manufacturer to lower their prices. Not the consumer's fault, but the consumer foots the bill. (or not, in the case of YT)
  • 1 0
 **$8-10 K*** sorry.
  • 1 0
 What is the blue bike pictured above?
  • 1 0
 2016 Trance SX
  • 1 0
 Thanks matey
  • 1 0
 great.
  • 1 0
 This is so messed up!
  • 1 2
 Every bike company should do this.
  • 1 3
 Cool
Below threshold threads are hidden







Copyright © 2000 - 2024. Pinkbike.com. All rights reserved.
dv56 0.035601
Mobile Version of Website