ah dude ive always wanted to make a bike with no welds...unfortunately i am poor and have no experience in metal and am 14 years old at the moment. That is sick, if only they could forge an entire hollow aluminum frame. Is it a production frame?
surely they are as good as tubes? apparently this frame is really stiff because of its I beam and raceface use an I beam for their cranks.
Hollow forgings are better for cranks - and hollow forgings are essentially tubes. Welded tubular cranks may even be better. Of course, you have to factor in a LOT of things beyond just the construction technique, but when it comes to twisting loads, tubes are superior.
I-beams are the best structures for loading in a single plane. That bike should be really strong near the head-tube, if the design and construction are good, but I'm still concerned about torsional stiffness.
surely they are as good as tubes? apparently this frame is really stiff because of its I beam and raceface use an I beam for their cranks.
Hollow forgings are better for cranks - and hollow forgings are essentially tubes. Welded tubular cranks may even be better. Of course, you have to factor in a LOT of things beyond just the construction technique, but when it comes to twisting loads, tubes are superior.
I-beams are the best structures for loading in a single plane. That bike should be really strong near the head-tube, if the design and construction are good, but I'm still concerned about torsional stiffness.
oh fair point, but how much of a torsional load is a bike encountering? and surely this frames torsional stiffness/ and yield point in areas like the headtube is alot better without welds?
oh fair point, but how much of a torsional load is a bike encountering? and surely this frames torsional stiffness/ and yield point in areas like the headtube is alot better without welds?
Torsional stiffness is very important to how solid a bike feels. The loading is a lot less than the in-plane loading, but it's still a real concern.
It's true that eliminating welds is a good thing, but drawn and cold-worked tubes are a lot better than cast metal. I'm not sure how those two factors offset one another.