Without doubt, the most interesting bike at this weekend’s
London Bike Show is Empire’s 3D printed titanium trail bike. Based on the brand’s innovative 6in-travel aluminium MX6, the titanium prototype is a collaboration with additive manufacturing firm
Renishaw and was built in the UK. We spoke to Empire’s Chris Williams about the project, and about 3D printing’s likely role in the future of the bike industry.
![Worlds First 3D printed Bike]()
The version on display was purely for show, but a rideable version has now been built and will be ridden in the coming weeks
The version on display at the show isn't rideable, but it had just come back from lab testing in Germany, where, Williams tells Pinkbike, “We tested the seat tower and surpassed the standard by six times, and that gave us the confidence to build the rest of the structure which we’re now going to test properly and ride. It’s genuinely the first time this has been done."
While we’ve seen 3D printing used in the bike industry before, notably on
Charge's titanium dropouts, this is the first time a complete frame has been built in this way.
![photo]()
All the parts of the bike are built on one block, then bonded together.
 | The complete bike is made up from nine separate components. Each component is designed to fit with a 250mm square build area no higher than 300mm, so we've tried to keep them as big as possible, then make a bonded joint on the end of each part that is designed to keep the adhesive within the joint. - Chris Williams |
“What I’ve done here is rather than building a small component that fits into the build area many times” says Williams, “I’ve taken large components and broken them into smaller pieces to fit into the build area. I think we’ll see more of this in the future. This is the very forefront of it, because I started this project six months ago, and the other week Renishaw told me that if I’d approached them six months earlier, they would have had to decline the project. It’s such cutting edge technology.”
3D printing makes the prototype frame 1400 grams, 700 grams lighter than the aluminium MX6 without forfeiting strength, thanks to
topological optimization of the structures.
Six months to build a frame probably sounds like quite a long time to you or I, but in engineering terms, it’s nothing. “We were starting from nothing” says Williams, “there’s nothing in the world like this, so we were starting from scratch so I think that timing is actually very quick. And to go to a rideable product that quickly is unheard of.”
All the components on the bike have a nominal wall thickness of 1mm, including the seat tower which looks like it’s a solid piece of metal but is actually hollow. “You can create structures that you can’t create in any other way” says Williams. “You can’t cast them, you can’t mill them because they’re hollow. You have to really change the way that you think in terms of your design to get something that works and is optimised for the process.”
![photo]()
The way the material is laid down creates a strange feel, looking somewhat like a carving with its soft finish. The seat mast on the right is completely hollow
At present the process uses titanium, but Renishaw is now working on transferring the process to aluminium. “Aluminium is a little bit tricky” says Williams, “because it reflects a lot of the energy of the laser, so you need a higher powered laser and a more expensive machine.”
Williams says that the current prototype is a showcase of what Empire and Renishaw are able to do, but that in the future it may make sense to create some type of hybrid structure, utilizing 3D printing for some parts whilst using more traditional methods for other parts.
![photo]()
Williams describes the project as a showcase for what both Empire and Renishaw are able to do. Also, notice the bonds on the tubes - a result of having to fit the manufacturing process into a small volume bloc
“We’ve always done things that are different, but we’ve always been upfront about it”, he says. “This is a showcase and a learning experience for everyone involved. It may well be that we end up with a hybrid structure of titanium and carbon components, we don’t know, but we’re never going to know until we try. This is just my first take - not how it should be, but how it could be.”
It's unlikely you'll see Empire's 3D printed Ti trail bike in a bike shop near you any time soon, but it's an incredible project and gives us a fantastic glimpse of the future of bike manufacturing. For the time being though, Empire are concentrating on selling their equally innovative
MX6, a UK made 6in-travel trail bike that easily swaps between 26in and 650b wheelsizes and comes in at under £1000 frame only.
![photo]()
For the moment, anyone wanting to try an Empire will have to make to with the British designed and manufactured aluminium MX6
empire-cycles.com
It's simple...
I see it first...
Here is an article about the costs of metal 3D printing:
www.techhive.com/article/217015/titanium_printer_lets_you_make_your_own_overpriced_3d_printed_parts.html
2) Graduate,
3) Sell your thesis to Empire, or start your own company ;-)
This seems unnecessary now but it may lead to great things.
Here is one:
Let's custom frame our bikes like how we are custom shelling/fitting our ski boots.
Boom, this comes out three years from now if no one had the idea before
I'm not convinced of the value here. I can see the benefits of topological optimization, but I have to wonder why we don't just forge/form two halves & resistance weld them down the middle with a piece in for the stays if it's a hard tail & then machine any necessary surfaces. Maybe it's too complicated to make the tooling. This just looks like a lot of time wasting welding to me. If you need certain internal profiles or parts inside parts I can see a benefit, but is it really the best way to optimize strength to weight ratios?
We'll still need to weld it though :/
brooklynmagicmaker.tumblr.com
wfp.asp.krakow.pl/wfp/jednostki.php?id_jednostki=102&&prace&&id_projektu=482
I'd be afraid that that seat might go up my ass… my balls would also probably be hangin through the middle
This Is The First Step!
You could even have custom internal cable routing with actual metal tubes inside, so you never lose the cable inside the frame.
If they got a bigger print area they could do a single piece entire front/rear triangle, that would be awesome.
@SoCalMX - You can make it look anything like you want! you could alter the frame in any way you like, have it tested and proved safe, then ride a totally custom bike! Obviously its not within everyone's limits to design and provide a model for a totally custom frame. But it's possible.
I held the seat post structure in my hands and its freakishly light, with a really nice finish too. The whole tech looks really sick. He was saying the reason the print area is so small is because it gets hotter at the top than at the bottom, so the larger sections tend to warp under their own weight at that kinda temperature. The top tube was a little warped on one of the examples he had, but it was ironed out on the real frame. Either way I'd say its just teething niggles.
Not to mention the way these parts are created, in layers, tends to make them less strong than proper cast, forged, fabricated parts. Notice its only the seat tower that has been tested?
The software they used to design the seat tower is very cool. It analyzes the loads then optimizes a sort of bone/lattice type structure for best strength/weight. Six times over a german test is impressive. Hell of a job for a first attempt here!
People have mentioned scaling the machines up to build the frame as 1 part, you could do that with sla (plastic, different production costs) but even plastic sla (which essentially this ti stuff is) machines dont seem to have progressed much beyond a 300mm cubed build volume, i think the whole laser sintering process is much harder to scale up.
Dont mean to be a downer on all this, id love it to become a reality, but im just wary of over hyping it all...
It's too bad they didn't Selective Laser Melt it though (SLM) or Electron Beam Melt it. With SLS you'll never get the same strength as traditional means simply because your not fully melting the material and therefore this "innovative" bike is little more then a novelty at best. Not that it's not impressive, just that it really falls short of how good it could have been.
This frame is made by selective laser sintering, or sls... its not an fdm like makerbots or the larger 3d printed stuff you'll have seen in chinese aircraft and the like.
So a 3D printer is a great way to make certain things, and a stupid, inefficient way to make other things.
I asked the big question "I want one now, how much money do you want for it??!?" ........ he said "about £20,000"
But, direct benefits to riders? weight? over carbon, doesn't seem likely.
Price? uuh, ti dually , nuf said.
.... bonded tubing overlaps.. seems like wasted material versus hydroform alloy or laid up carbon. to say nothing of tuned stiffness.
...and at the end is a result that looks just like my 1995 Proflex Animal... not bad for 1996...
sigh, sorry, the whole package just turned me into a hater...
The engineering "inner game" is just not compelling in the world of white-knuckle, big-grin riding....
Different material different process, but both are alternate methods from the norm.
IIRC, the Kirk frame road like a brick, but that was for a hardtail. It might be worth revisiting for a FS bike, though now it has to compete with carbon.
And then it hit me. Modular bikes! How awesome would that be! Choose every single spec and dimension to your own personal preference! head tube size and angle, seat tube diameter, bottom bracket type, drop out type etc etc. Brilliant!
I guess don't do any big drops on it haha
Offcourse no one wants to do drops while sitting. But in case your feet slip off your pedal when you land, or you do some kind of superman or something and you're not able to pull it back correctly, it's nice to have a seat there that won't break down on you when you need your seat to cushion your fall.
Again: I'm only talking about the situation, not at all about this bike.
This bike looks smoking hot and I have big respect for the people who made this piece of innovation become reality
"Six months to build a frame probably sounds like quite a long time to you or I, but in engineering terms, it’s nothing."
No joke. I work on projects maybe 1/10th as ambitious and complex, and they take twice as long. An amazing feat, to be sure.
I'm a big dude. I'd hate to be the first one to come down and have that sucker break in half right there. I can see a big future in this technology for this industry and someone has to do this first. But I don't like that execution.
I see a bright future for printing, especially for the industry I'm in. The thing about what we do, is we are the ones that come up with the ways and processes involved in production to reduce cycle time, labor hours, cost, etc (as an ME). I will be working explicitly with lasers over the next few years and additive manufacturing. It will be on us to make this technology work for us. As we progress, so will the technology on the machines; improvement will happen around the board. We will for sure find a way to make these processes beneficial for us.
As far as this article goes, I think this is beyond awesome. Yes, very expensive right now, but there will be advances in technology. I am glad I get to be apart of it in my lifetime!! As far as owning one of these, maybe someday.... I'll start with printing my own parts first.
For anyone who wants to know about how it was done, I wrote a blog about it michaelaldridge.com/queens-baton-glasgow-2014-design
wfp.asp.krakow.pl/wfp/jednostki.php?id_jednostki=102&&prace&&id_projektu=482
11-14-18-21-25-29-33-37-42 for example would be nicely spaced out gaps... Three 3T jumps followed by four 4T and finally one 5T.
Then the idea of printing stuff at homw will never happen becase it will never be economicaly convenient. It is still far away enough to be able to print action figures at home from plastic. It is hard enough to motivate a purchase a better laser printer for home use to be able to print pictures from holidays, and we get ambitions to print metal parts? Sure you can! It's just that you got to be Donald Trumps grand son twat
www.bikerumor.com/2014/02/03/forget-titanium-worlds-first-3d-carbon-fiber-printer-online/#more-72585
But still 5000 for a small box, that can print you things not larger than 3d vagina or rectum (you skip the embarassment of going to the shop yourself so got a point there!) What about the material, what about the 3d model? Will they be on torrents or rather cost lots? Making 3d models isn' easy, not mentioning making them usable for 3d printing. Dream on though, I apologize I don't want to take anyone's dreams away
dirtmag.co.uk/news/the-carbon-dungeon-dirt-134.html
www.ulule.com/bikepark-geneve