We're a fickle bunch these days, with news of so-and-so's fresh carbon rim not causing the hubbub it once did. We get it; it's light and black and carbon and expensive and probably not worth the price when you really think about it. And when it comes to aluminum rims... I've got a freshly painted wall that I need to watch dry, thank you very much.
But Spank Industries - who've always shunned carbon fiber - are doing some genuinely interesting things with their aluminum rims, especially the part where they fill them with green foam that hardens up. More interesting than you thought, right? Yeah, these aren't your run of the mill alloy hoops.
Spike 350 Vibrocore Wheelset• Intended use: trail / all-mountain / enduro
• Diameter: 27.5'' or 29'' (tested)
• Rim width: 30.5mm (inner)
• Vibrocore foam-filled rim cavity
• Hub Compatibility: All of 'em
• Tape and valve included
• Weight: 2,078-grams (29'')
• MSRP: $699 USD
• More info:
www.spank-ind.com The green foam is the Vibrocore in Spank's Spike 350 Vibrocore wheelset and the claim is that it's there to help with vibration damping. The $699 USD, 2,078-gram wheelset is made for everything from trail riding to downhill use, and you can get 'em in both 27.5'' and 29'' sizes.
With a low height and thinner walls, the 350 Vibrocore rim is said to offer more vertical compliance.
DesignYou don't need to be a marketing scientist to know that having a long list of features is gonna help you sell whatever it is you're hoping people buy. Truth is, however, that a lot of those cleverly named features don't really add up to much more than that, just another bullet point in the catalog.
But whether it works as claimed or not, Spank's Vibrocore foam-filled rim design is more than just a bullet point. In fact, it might be the most interesting thing to happen to aluminum hoops since someone figured out how to design them with more than a single wall.
The foam goes in soft but then hardens up as it dries.
Here's the claim. First, we're supposed to stop calling it 'just' foam. It's a ''
Proprietary, biodegradable, complex foam core of precisely controlled density,'' and Spank says that it ''
Reduces vibrations or ‘noise’. The low density, pressurized core performs a similar function to the soft tissue inside bones, increasing inner wall strength and absorbing vibrations.'' This, along with the rim's relatively low height, is supposed to make for a wheel that's able to damp certain types of vibrations better than a traditional design.
The Vibrocored Oozy 350 rim comes in at a still respectable 545-grams in the 29'' size, or just 40-grams more than the standard Oozy hoop. Foam doesn't weight much. It also adds about $30 USD to the cost, with the stuffed 350 going for $129 USD on its own.
Spank's been doing some clever things with aluminum, and in their own factory, for many years now. One of them is the 'W' cross-section to the rim that's said to increase strength over the traditional 'U' shape; think corrugated sheets of aluminum and you'll get the idea.
The other neat bit worth pointing out are the three rows of 0.2mm tall ridges that run the length of the rim's sidewall and bed - you can spot them in the photo below. You've probably already figured out what's going on: More friction between these ridges and the tire's bead should mean fewer burps. Spank says that it helps to do that for both tubed and tubeless setups, too.
Spot those ridges on the rim's sidewall? They're supposed to help keep the tire from burping or unseating entirely.
The rest of the Spike 350 Vibrocore wheelset is pretty straightforward. There are 32 triple butted, J-bend spokes laced three-cross (and 32 brass nipples) to a set of nice looking hubs that turn on sealed bearings. You can choose between XD or a normal freehub, and inside there's a conventional three-pawl, steel drive-ring setup that you get at by using a 17mm cone wrench on one side and the
handle of another wrench into the axle slots on the other.
Spank has done their customers a solid by not just making sure the hubs can fit everything from quick-release 100/135mm to all the different thru-axle options, but they've also laser etched each designation onto the caps. I have a drawer full of hub parts that I'll probably never use because I don't have the slightest clue what they fit, so I like this simple detail.
The hubs are straightforward, and the interchangeable endcaps are laser etched so you'll always know what axle size they fit.
PerformanceSo, does this green stuff actually make a difference or is it just there for the bullet points? The 350 Vibrocore wheels were bolted onto a Trek Slash owned by someone who goes through alloy rims quicker than I go through tires, which is absurd. Yeah, Squamish, BC, isn't easy on bike gear. Reliability and feel are the questions here, though, so it's an ideal location.
The Vibrocore guts don't make this rim indestructible, but they did brush off the kind of abuse that claimed a handful of other rims over prior months. Giant dents, flat spots, and cracks took out the others, but the 350s lasted longer than any other wheel, especially the one on the back of the bike. Not only did the rear wheel stay relatively true, the rim's sidewalls didn't fold over like cardboard when it was smashed into the backside of a rock. That's a win in my books.
It wasn't all smooth sailing, though, with the rear wheel needing a re-tensioning after just three rides and then some more love required four weeks down the road. That said, the rim was still straight and dent-free, but the build definitely required a few spins of the spoke wrench to bring the tension back up. Keep in mind that it'd be around this time that any other aluminum rim that's been on the back of this bike would go into the bin, but the 350 hoops kept on trucking.
It's also worth noting that there were less burping incidents compared to other alloy rims, be it through a hard corner or a sideways landing, so maybe there's something to Spank's funky ribbed sidewalls. I always like it when my tire doesn't come off mid-ride.
The 350s stood up to some serious abuse, lasting longer than any other aluminum rim that one particular test rider has ever used.
Feel is the other talking point, with Spank saying that the design offers a degree of radial compliance, presumably more than your average carbon rim. This one's a bit more ambiguous, however, and especially when they're attached to a supple, active enduro race bike. One bit of feedback that does stand out is that they felt a bit "dead," for lack of a better term, which could be the foam core doing what it's supposed to be doing. Either way, they were much more reliable than other wheels that have seen the same abuse.
The hubs proved to be trouble-free as well, and while they eventually needed some love, aka a re-tensioning, the 350s were more reliable than any other wheelset that's called that Slash home.
Pinkbike's Take:  | Spank's Spike 350 Vibrocore wheels proved to be more reliable than other alloy wheels that we've had on the same bike being ridden down the same trails, and that's enough for me to say that there are some benefits to these foam-filled hoops, especially given that the 40-gram penalty is pretty minimal. — Mike Levy |
Short answer: No
Long answer: Nooooooooooooooooooooooo
Does this foam make old trashed rims useless as a track-side noise maker for race days?
What do you think?
Short answer: Yes
Just like their Vibrocore bars - kick ass over carbon, do they make a difference: YES
**I ditched my Renthal setup for Vibrocore and they are waaaaay better
I rode on vibrocore bars for several months and couldn't tell a damn thing
I couldn't tell any difference.
Will UCI be testing for this and if so then how do would one explain I have more than normal red blood cells due to my rims and not EPO?
Suggestion if the answer to the first question is a Yes: Could they brand these as Spank Armstrong?
Cannon upvote u enough
No; plastic fantastic
Jokes off - i have an spank spike 800 vibrocore handlebar on my dh bike, and it feels better than any other alloy handlebar
So i think v-core wheelset should be felt well to
/sorry for my english
I agree the actual rim design is the main contributor of strength, but I was surprised how dense it was.
Another benefit of the bead bite and Cush Core combo is my DHF 2.5 DH wire bead tires sealed up tubeless with minimal hassle.
Seems like I've got a lighter and more reliable setup than the last two park seasons. Sweet!
My only caveat...setting them up tubeless without using the Spank Fratelli tape is a bastard. That W profile means the tape has to be very flexible across its width to properly adhere to the rim and maintain a seal.
There's a definite difference in feel vs my prior Stans Mk III. Feel better in rock gardens but kinda dead on flow trails. My 2016 Schawlbes did not mount, but DHF/DHR went on easy and held air without sealant (for a few days, anyway). Inflated with a regular pump. Spank has a great reputation in dirt jumping. Spoon 32 is indestructible and I've seen DJs with Race 28s on them as well (though I hear they do fail as rear wheels).
One other note. Since they're a bit more forgiving, lately I've been running higher pressure on flow trails to reduce rolling resistance. End up with a DJ like feel on a trail bike. Fun times!
Oh and I bought into the Vibrocore bar Koolaid back in 2016. Found a set for half off and decided to give it a go. On a 170/160mm bike, hmm, I dunno, but on my 140/125 they're appreciated. They're not all that much more expensive than other alloy bars and they're way cheaper than carbon, and they come in garish bright colors, so now they're on all my bikes.
It supposed to work on the pringle-ing type deformation, like damping a cymbal ring? I thought that's where rim stiffness was meant to be king, and spoke tension isolating the buzz from the bike?
When you say that Mike, is this also compared against the standard non foam filled spank rim?
I propose a Crunchocore filling (you know the Crunchie candy bar).
Combine this with Barelli's Baguette Insert and voila ....
Vibration damping, tire stability and instant solution to epic ride bonk all in one.
Great for the planet too !
THANKS SPANK!!!!!!
I think PB should do some proper testing of this nature on claimed beneficial features of anything! But then again who will want them to test their product to find out it's all a load of rubbish.
Most relevant for me, may i get it in blue? I don’t like green
cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2363/5997/files/Spank_VibrocoreTM_Frequency_Analysis_Test_Report.pdf?17652700425391016425
Wish I'd done that years ago.
www.instagram.com/p/BekRLrSBDnC/?igshid=1c4d0wtyhxbk2
NEWMEN EG 30 everyday ..
Just cracked a Carbon rim two days after I get them. Back to NEWMEN....
Race 33 rims are strong as fook too. My Nomad fell off the back of my car at 110km/h on the freeway. Front wheel was undamaged. Rear wheel was about 3mm out of true. Vibrocore bar was straight which was unbelievable. I replaced it anyway. The stem took a beating though. One of the Spike pedals got a rough bearing after that.
I cannot recommend Spank stuff highly enough.
But Spanks W-shape is simply a selling point. Merida did the same with their frames back in the days. The foam is there to supposedly dampen vibrations which is impossible to determine. Many people were claiming that first carbon rims and bars were more compliant than alloy which was pure horse shit caused by post purchase rationalization. Those spanks may be quiter though. When you run no insert and super thin tyres on rocky terrain it may be a nice feature to have
Imagine bending a ruler flat and then upright... which is stiffer?
@werics: Exactly. The qalititative lab test can be performed no problem, the issue is that human has to then recognize the difference, so it is worthless. That is why I mentioned people claiming that their X carbon bar dampens vibrations, and I mean Race Face bars in particular, where opinions go from "amazing" to "roughest crap that I ever rode". If Spank could provide two sets of rims, one with the foam and one without for a blind test in a sample group of at least 20 riders then we could talk. They could use black alloy and brass nipples to compensate for weight difference. If the result comes out at least 70%-30% liking the foam filled rims, we can talk. Until then. No.
I'm a rim smasher and built these up for myself. They've remained nearly true and dent free despite regular abuse on front range trails near Denver as well as a few Moab trips.
I built these up to replace some carbon rims I obliterated.
Maybe your buddy's got a case of JRA. tacoing while turning seems implausible. Tacoing because his front wheel lost traction and turned perpendicular to the bike would occur with nearly any rim.
www.bike-magazin.de/komponenten/lenker_vorbauten/test-2016-spank-vibrocore/a33999.html
Snake oil, humbug and placebo.
I really like the Oozy rims, but due to the fact that they are pushing their Vibrocore nonsense, I think I will move on to Newmen rims.
cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2363/5997/files/Spank_VibrocoreTM_Frequency_Analysis_Test_Report.pdf?17652700425391016425