Marin County, California, is often credited as being the birthplace of mountain biking, but even though it's been nearly 50 years since those early pioneers first put tires to dirt, the area is still embroiled in controversy about exactly where mountain bikes are allowed to ride. The recent arrest of two cyclists for riding on Marin open space land continues the saga.
According to
an article in the Marin Independent Journal, Dr. Paul Cameron and Dr. David Carbonell were spotted riding on a trail that's closed to mountain bikers, and rode away when a deputy tried to stop them. Both were later apprehended and charged with riding their bikes illegally, along with resisting arrest. Dr. Carbonell is the co-founder of the New Trails Paradigm Group, an organization that has publicly expressed its frustration with the exclusion of mountain bikers from trails in the Marin area.
The article describing the incident states, "Marin County Park and Open Space Superintendent Ari Golan said the fine for riding illegally on open space land is $45 for a first offense. Golan said additional court costs, however, increase the total cost to $199. The fine for a second offense is $100, which amounts to a total cost of $410. All violations after that carry a fine of $150, which actually adds up to $615, Golan said. The charge of resisting arrest carries a maximum fine of $1,000 and imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year."
The turmoil and frustration surrounding mountain biking in Marin is no secret - Vernon Felton's
op-ed, which was inspired by the announcement that radar guns were going to be used to enforce bicycle speed limits, did an excellent job of illustrating exactly what the situations is like, but unfortunately, it doesn't seem as if it's going to change any time soon. As Vernon so aptly put it, "Marin County has been an absolutely horrid place to actually ride a mountain bike since, oh, about 1983."
......just kidding. His case got thrown out because he took an anger management course.
Trespassing: you get arrested and fined. Reckless endangerment and assault: no biggie.
Riding at night, an enemy of the state. Who know?
Too bad, since there are so many trails that could be great for riding.. But, folks over there just don't want to share..
Any time a trail is suggested to be opened up to bikes, even to avoid roads for safety reasons, people lose their freaking minds and shoot it down..
Yet, the folks that manage the land want bike access to only happen on current trails.. It's a no win situation.. Can't get more access on current trails and won't build any new ones.. cyclists in Marin are F*ckd unless they poach.. So they do. it's all they've got.
Keep up the good fight, I'm sure a lot of the up north folks appreciate it.
Marin has an over abundance of cyclists on the roads. Everything from tourists on rental bikes, families out for a leisurely ride with thier kids, to the dedicated “spandex warriors”. They are all forced to share the streets with automobile drivers. The streets become so congested at times that road rage incidents are a normal everyday occurrence. The bottom line being, there are just too many bicycles, and most don’t obey the traffic rules. Because of that, they’ve ruined it for the rest of us.
I couldn’t possibly imagine taking that mess of people, and allowing them to ride on the mountain trails. It would not be an enjoyable experience... for anyone. Hopefully this perspective is helpful.
@Sammyfish
Makes me want to cruise up to Marin with a group of buddies and f*ck with the locals...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJQJeB3hruA
It's f**king ridiculous in California. For a place that was once know for free thinking the state is the enemy of anything fun if it's incongruent with some rich a*shole's activities.
1. the open space deputy's time
2. the two Marin sheriff's deputies time
3. the gas it took to drive to the dude's house to apprehend him
4. the subsequent court time
5. the time it took for two sheriff's Lt. and one superintendent to make statements about this whole thing
Throw in the potential harm the deputy could have caused himself or the cyclist by chasing him down and grabbing him then multiply it by the staggering 27 incidents in 2017 and I'm CERTAIN that the cyclists are causing more damage to the trail and to society by riding illegally. I'm all for upholding the law and yes, the guys were breaking it, but this seems like one that may need a little reworking.
Hopefully they're not that way in every state, but while there was a time when I could say 'well, not every cop is worthless', the older I get, the less confidence I have in that statement-at least in the areas where mountain biking takes place(where I live), i.e. suburban, low-crime rate
I'm sure the cops that chased them had their lights spinning in full force, sirens whaling, calling for back-up. Heck..they prolly even called in a chopper(or two).
Clearly it was the 'big' bust of the day. Heck, maybe even month.
The two 'criminals'(doctors) need to spend the money on good attorneys and fight it. If for no other reason than to cost the county $$$$$$, and teach 'em a lesson
reviews.mtbr.com/anti-mountain-biking-fanatic-mike-vandeman-arrested-for-assault-with-a-deadly-weapon-against-two-bikers
Tom Boss, off-road director of the Marin County Bicycle Coalition, declined to comment on the incident.
Boss wrote in an email, “MCBC advocates for improved mountain bike access by creating safe, fun and inclusive trail environments for all. We do this through collaboration, not confrontation.”
AS FECKLESS AS IMBA and SACREMENTO in ACTUALLY GOVERNING!
ALL IS "sic" NORMAL IN KALIFORNIA.....
If you want to know why laws are the way they are, follow the money. Sadly true in blue states and red.
Don't run and don't lie.
You can talk your way out of most anything if you follow those suggestions. I tried the former and learned the hard way.
Weed is now legal, so maybe that is going to make the LEOs look for other ways to make money writing tickets.
I have ridden across CA and NV and have never been stopped any place else by the law or locals.
I do agree that Marin in general is anti MTB, but running from the cops is stupid. These guys brought this on themselves.
I’m also curious to know how this cop caught the guy he got. I’d hope he was on a bike or dirt bike. Cause if he caught that guy on foot, damn that guy must suck.
Good job "land of the free" btw...
Marin is in District 2 - extends all the way up California's coast to the Oregon border (through Mendocino, Eureka, etc). Rep is Jared Huffman, Democrat. Google/Wikipedia is an awesome tool.
Not that it matters because he (and all the other congressional reps) have far bigger fish to fry - this issue isn't on the radar of state reps (nor should it be) - this is a local/county issue, and obviously Marin County like the rest of NoCal is a mess when it comes to local park space balancing the access needs of hikers and bikers (forget horses, I won't go there).
Anyways, thought you wouldn't mind getting some basic civics from a 9th generation Californian/sheep. Sorta like Kumail Nanjiani's take on racists - "What bugs me about racism is the inaccuracy. Do the research! A more informed racist is a better racist!"
@phclaw
Missed the point entirely, but that’s liberals for you.
naturalresources.house.gov/calendar/eventsingle.aspx?EventID=403567
It's logical to argue the ban is OK - there's a ton of public land out there, right? That is until a place you love to ride is suddenly taken away. I've ridden the Boulder-White Clouds trails in Idaho. They are epic and now they are off limits. What's going on in Montana is arguably worse. Lands being designated as wilderness study areas by the forest service before ever going to Congress and being treated as Wilderness. Hundreds if not thousands of miles of trails have been taken out this way.
As for the GOP's intent, can you explain why you believe this to be a trojan horse? I've heard that argument many times but after reading the proposed amendment I just don't see how it can gets from removing the ban to industrial development.
People like him don’t think. They just talk.
I ride illegal trails occasionally (on a military base no less). If they start enforcing it and I get caught, you know what I'm going to do? Stop and take the consequences.
Though in my situation it'll be Military Police one of whose jobs is to secure nuclear weapons, so it would be silly to try and run and we have plenty of great trails, so I'm riding that one just cause I like it and not cause it is hard to find paces to ride.
www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/bc-woman-gets-three-years-probation-for-sabotaging-mountain-bike-trails/article28332441
Also, @rpinney206, Evergreen is by far the high bar for how a mountain bike organization should be run and should develop new trails. As someone who has worked with Evergreen since 2010, they have been doing awesome for a long time, you're just seeing the fruits of that hard work now. It all started with Colonnade, as maligned as it has been that was the project that opened doors.