Powered by Outside

Help me pick a bike that suits my skill level

PB Forum :: Beginners
Help me pick a bike that suits my skill level

If you are looking for support please visit the Trailforks Help Center or the Pinkbike Help Center.
Trailforks/Pinkbike staff does occasionally check these forums, but this is mainly for other users to help each other.
 Post Message | Latest Comment
Author Message
flag Mlodney
Posted: Jun 11, 2023 at 16:20 Quote
Ok, so I have 2 bikes, and I need to sell one. I don't have the space to keep both, and could use the money, but I am having trouble deciding which one to keep.
I am very much a casual rider at this point, sticking to around town commuting and pretty mild trails. While I don't have any interest in getting crazy into mountain biking, I am interested in trying out something a bit more technical.
The bikes I have:

2019 trek marlin 6. Obviously it's nothing fancy and a pretty basic bike, but it does meet my current needs and riding skill level, and could manage on something a bit more technical, but it's limited.

2013 specialized stumpjumper. It has a few upgrades on it, making it a pretty nicely setup mountain bike. It's more bike than I need at this point and would make me more money if I sell it.

The trem was my only bike until I got the specialized for a wicked deal, and I am having trouble deciding which to keep. So, if you were in my shoes, which would you pick?
flag cedarbremner
Posted: Jun 11, 2023 at 18:51 Quote
Realistically, if you are doing mostly commuting and easy trails, the Marlin will be enough capability for you, but each bike has some advantages and disadvantages.

Firstly, the Stumpy is- it was- obviously the higher end bike. It probably has nicer components and I assume it is full suspension as well. However, due to its age you may find yourself dealing with more quirks and issues. Also, finding replacement parts and upgrades might be harder.

On the other hand, the Marlin is an entry-level but extremely solid bike. I would trust basically anything that comes from Trek with my life, your bike included. It’s newer and therefore will be easier to service and upgrade. Being a hardtail, it will also pedal a bit better for commuting. The other thing about hard tails is that they will craft you into a great rider if you learn on one. They are less forgiving, but teach great habits.

Essentially, it comes down to which bike you like better. Take a good long look at them and say “which one do I want to spend hours of my life riding?” Both are great options.

 


Copyright © 2000 - 2026. Pinkbike.com. All rights reserved.
dv65 0.007818
Mobile Version of Website