I have tried WTB, but the bump up at the nose was hard on the taint. My Specialized Phenom Comp 143mm that came on my 2019 Stumpy has been very comfy. I do tilt it down a bit. I'm 6', 170lbs. It's the only saddle that I actually can say I liked in 25yrs of riding. You could probably find a new takeoff in the buy & sell.
I struggled with a lot of saddles too and the Chromag Trailmaster is the best I've ever ridden. Had one now for 4 years and no comfort issues at all anymore.
I also had a decent experience with an older WTB womens saddle that they don't make anymore. Yeah, I know, imagine a MAN sitting on saddle that has is marketed to WOMEN? It's insane! But seriously, most women have wider sit bones than the average man and it just so happened to align with mine so it worked really well on my commuter road bike. But that bike was stolen and never was able to find the same saddle.
I've heard good things about Specialized Lithia - they call it a womens saddle but the big cutouts in the middle and back, and all the cush apparently do wonders for those older fellas
My wife just got this saddle, and damn if it isn't really comfortable.