Red Bull Round Up - The Winners have been chosen

 i agree and in all honesty it sucked it was really over done with a lot of random editing and it was supposed to be a trailer not some like stupid story thing and it had to be 2 min his is 2 min and 15 seconds so its not even legal. i like the one red bull chose a lot better

 i couldn't finish kpeek's video, it was definitely not my thing. to many effects and what not. i like editing that makes the riding look better, not editing that makes the editer look good.

 x2 guys. Im dissapointed that Kpeek won. But congrats anyways.

 So is your use of the english language n3lson666x. Some people on this site can't just enjoy things like POD and competitions such as this, they have to be negative and dumb down the joy of winning. I don't enjoy getting POD's or VOD's because of the constant flux of negative comments you get about them.

 Sweet congrats to the winner i'm at least glade i made in the top 10!

 YEAH BROCK!!!!!

 weird to see all the complaints with positive props,you guys voted for him to win.if ti didnt have the pver edit like freaking lighting every 2 seconds and goofy fireballs falling down,i think the riding clips were chosen so good the song suited it and the footage was clear. i liked some of his editing moves just not the realy lame ones.

 Pinkbike should do another video editing contest soon! I love em'.

 ohhh that would be niccce

 I dont wanna look like an ass and i know im gonna get neg props but Voting ended the day before it got VOD.

 i was going to mention that too... it was VOD after voting ended..

 ok my bad either way congrats kpeek

 i think its just a bit cheezy and over the top. fun, but by no means professional.

 i do agree totally with your opinion... i already realised long time ago that it is going to happen yet again, by it i mean same as what happened with seasons recut, but what the heck... in my opinion there were far more worthy candidate for the win. the votes are rigged and there is nothing we can do... the sheep follow the blind all the time and that is why we still live in a stone age filled with destruction and pollution...

and congrats to Brock, because he definately deserves the prizes due to an excellent work being done

 its really not 'off the wall' im pretty sure it's one big plugin pack that you can get for after effects. if we were talking about editing, its not that great. the cuts are slow, as a viewer, you're always waiting for something to happen, theres a lot of time between action in this cut compared to others. the footage is dark and like many others have said it distracts from the riding, which is what the event is about. i dont want to be bitching about things, but i wouldn't ever consider this off the wall at all.

 yeh but to be honest id rather have a sound track where the lead singers voice isnt breaking during the song

 "off the wall" effects hmm... mountain biking is about control, flow of motion, grace and a mouth-dropping spectacle. by putting too many effects (such as sparks or nuclear explosions into the background) makes the sport look cheap and even unworthy to watch... it really felt like i was watching a cheap action flick with JCVD or Wesley Snipes

ask yourselves the question: did The Collective require top-notch effects in order to show that their videos truly stood out from the rest of the industry's produce? hopefully the answer to this question is known by those who have seen their movies and which

well time cannot be turned around already, but a popularity contests are the worst of them all, because there is no way one can change or monitor the votes due to these days there are dynamic IPs and all sort of other scrips, which cannot be distinguished by an admin...

i though that the contest will be changed to real judging this time round... but i laid my expecations a bit too high.

although yet again thanks for the contest's material, which would not have been seen by the rest of the folks of the mountain freeriding community

 i wasn't saying the plugin did ALL the effects for him radek. I'm saying that at my work which uses after effects we've definitly come across a plugin pack that has a large majority of those effects in it. if i could dig up the name of it i would but we no longer have it because we don't require it for our use.

and i also am well aware that he received the most user votes, and have never debated that or the fact that he won, i was just stating my opinion (to which i am allowed) and what i know.

 well i'm not disappointed at all, if that is what you are implying towards... i was using the footage to kill some time and see what will be the response of other folks about it... when i enter the competitions i never expect to win, because the chance is so little... it is like a lottery.

about the monitoring: well that was a bit rude from you by saying that and yet i know that my knowledge is limited in this sphere, but my friends' are not... because you can't even imagine how many opportunities there are available so that it will look like one is getting a lot of unique votes...

you should have made it as it was said in the contest, that it will be the Red Bull crew that will decide who will win... in my opinion

it is my opinion and there is no need for insults to come, due to what has been said

 Lets do it again! More Footage PLEASE!

 The viewers (read you and the rest of the folks on the site) voted and kpeek won. Red Bull chose brock so he won too, so your kinda talking in circles.

 well i didnt vote for him. but whats interesting is that people say his sucked and get lots of + props or they say he was good and get lots of negative props so its strange that he won.