This is the rotor I bought from georgi-g (Pinkbike user) in Baltimore, Maryland. The aluminum spider was bent, there was the quite visible crack as per this pic, and there were multiple edge deformations as if someone had tried to true the rotor with an adjustable wrench. Georgi was completely unapologetic and willing only to refund the price of the rotor, not the shipping. Had to open a dispute with PayPal, they decided in my favor and gave me a refund for the rotor and the original shipping. Lost a couple dollars to return the rotor to Georgi. Throughout it all he has been an utter pain to deal with and has never admitted fault or taken responsibility for selling a shit item.