eMTB Week
Pinkbike is running a week-long focus on eMTBs. We’ll be sharing reviews, news, and opinion pieces all week in addition to our regular coverage.
Read our stance on eMTBs here.
Bergamont have supplied us with some killer test bikes in the past, with their Trailster 140mm travel trail bike still being one of my favorite trail bikes for its solid feel and good manners. The E-Trailster hopes to build on that same and concept with the addition of a Bosch Performance CX motor, a 500wh battery, and a chain-growth neutralizing idler wheel to minimize torque feedback from the simple, single-pivot rear suspension.
The E-Trailster 9.0 we tested is their top of the range model, retailing at a modest (compared to other eMTB's) €5199 and is spec'ed with a RockShox Pike fork and a Monarch shock; a SRAM EX1 drivetrain; Magura MT4 brakes; a Sun Ringlé wheelset; a predominantly Answer cockpit; and it showcases Manitou's new Jack dropper seatpost.
E-Trailster 9.0 Details• Intended use: trail, all-mountain
• Travel: 140mm / 150mm
• Bosch Performance Line CX motor
• Bosch 500wh PowerPack battery
• Suspension: High pivot swingarm, with idler wheel torque neutralizer.
• 27.5" wheels
• SRAM EX1 drivetrain
• Sizes: XS, S, M, L
• Weight: 23.4 kg (actual, w/o pedal, DH/SG tires)
• Price: €5199
•
www.bergamont.com Details and BuildThe E-Trailster has a 6066 alloy, welded aluminum frame, that includes a tapered head tube and internal cable routing. The axle spacing is not Boost width: 142mm rear and 100mm front - which arguably, is outdated for a 2017 eMTB. I'm not a boost fanboy, but if you are spending a chunk of money on a bike in 2017, it seems like a bad idea to drop behind trend when it's clear to see that the industry has made the decision to support Boost. On that same subject, the narrow, 24mm rims are also outdated, as were the narrow and mid-weight Maxxis Forecaster 2.35" width, Exo casing tires These were switched after ride number one to something heavier duty from the depths of my shed - a Super Gravity Magic Mary from Schwalbe and a Maxxis High Roller in the DH casing.
The suspension is controlled by a 150mm travel Pike RCT3 fork, and a Monarch RT3 HV shock handles its 140mm travel rear suspension. SRAM's EX1 8-speed eMTB specific drivetrain and cranks connect the Bosch motor to the rear hub and to stop the bike, Bergamont chose Magura MT4 brakes, which appear under-powered. Their four pot brothers would seem the more sensible choice. Always choose extra power when weight isn't really an e-issue.
Suspension Design The aluminum frame uses a high swingarm pivot-point, located above and behind the Bosch motor. The seat stay pivot is located very close to the rear wheel's axle and there is a short rocker link mounted to the seat tube to drive the shock. An idler wheel and retention guide are located on the main pivot axis. The chain runs over the idler to eliminate chain feedback - similar to what we see on Commencal's latest downhill bike and some classic downhill bikes of the past.
Geometry/Sizing I opted for the XL sized frame, which has a 463mm reach, 66.5º head angle, a 74º seat angle and a 475mm chainstay. The bottom bracket sits 18mm below the wheel axles. It's interesting to note that the E-Trailster only increases by 10mm per size, from the medium up to the extra large - not a significant difference in frame size compared to the wide range of body types that will be riding them.
MotorBergamont uses the Performance CX Line motor from Bosch, along with the external 500wh PowerPack. The Bosch motor is currently the most popular on the market and the 500wh battery is one of the largest and most commonly used. Our bike came with the Bosch Purion display, with the software updated to 'eMTB' mode, which is now a free upgrade for on all Bosch powered bikes. This mode gives the rider the access to the whole range of power available, rather than switching between modes – pedal harder and you get more power, spin along gently and you will get the least assistance.
Specifications
Specifications
|
Price
|
$5199 |
|
Travel |
140mm |
|
Rear Shock |
Rock Shox Monarch RT3 200x57 mm |
|
Fork |
Rock Shox Pike RCT3 27.5", 150 mm, |
|
Headset |
Cane Creek 40/15 series |
|
Cassette |
SRAM CS XG-899, 11-48t |
|
Crankarms |
SRAM FC EX1 |
|
Chainguide |
BGM pulley with chain guide |
|
Bottom Bracket |
Bosch, ISIS |
|
Rear Derailleur |
SRAM RD EX1, long cage |
|
Chain |
SRAM EX1 |
|
Shifter Pods |
SRAM SL EX1, 1x8-speed, trigger-shifter |
|
Handlebar |
Answer Pro Taper 750 AM, |
|
Grips |
BGM Race, MTB, double density, clamp version |
|
Brakes |
Magura MT4, hydraulic disc brake, Storm HC rotor: 180/180 mm |
|
Wheelset |
Sun Ringlé Charger Expert AL |
|
Tires |
Maxxis Forekaster, folding, EXO, 27.5x2.35 |
|
Seat |
SDG Falcon RL |
|
Seatpost |
Manitou Jack dropper post, 31.6 mm, 125 mm travel, |
|
Climbing and Trail The E-Trailster is one of the easiest eMTB's for climbing I've reviewed so far. The massive, 475mm-long chainstays help to keep the front end down, even when giving it
voll gas on the climbs. The saddle position is the furthest forward in relation to the bottom bracket (180mm behind the BB on a horizontal plane) compared to any other eMTB I have tested, this gave a central position to attack the climbs.
The lack of pedal feedback through the chain and great support from the suspension lets it float over rough terrain easily, and it doesn't wallow with the shock's compression lever left open. I am finding that eMTB's require less anti-squat than a normal bike. The majority of the power now comes from the smooth, circular drive of the motor, instead of the jabby motion of a human's legs, which are not designed specifically for pedaling.
Bosch's latest eMTB specific power mode is fantastic. It makes tackling technical sections and tight corners simpler, as it's easier to feed the power gently through the cranks, and then gives you a boost when you drop the hammer in order to pop up and over obstacles. Using the normal Trail or Turbo modes often left you overcooking it around tight corners, or not having the power needed for short boosts up and over short climbs.
Descending This is where the E-Trailster gets interesting. The mere 140mm travel, combined with the added weight of motor and battery, might be the best rear suspension system I have ever used on any bike, massively outperforming its actual travel. Plowing straight through rough sections, I thought the forks were broken. I felt impacts through the fork, but rarely did those impacts affect the rear suspension when the back wheel struck an obstacle.
As I have found in the past with suspension that use high pivots with no pedal kickback, the action through braking bumps and big hits is unbeatable, especially for flat pedal riders, who will find their feet always planted however rough it gets. Hitting huge holes or landing drops, the anticipated kick into the ankles never came and bottom out was almost unnoticeable. Such suspensions are normally compromised by pedal bobbing – highlighted by poor pedaling technique, but this issue doesn't come to light on the electric-assisted machine. The downside of this appears to be a difficulty in creating grip on smooth and flat corners. When you want to drive the rear wheel into the ground to generate grip, it seems to move off line and start to slide.
The Trailster outperforms what we would expect from its listed numbers, probably due to the heavy weight and improved sprung to unsprung mass ratio when compared to a non-assisted bike. The front portion of the bike could be slacker for even better descending, but that might just get me into high-speed trouble. The whopping 475mm chainstay length comes in to play here, giving big stability everywhere. Manuals were a little tough to start with, but a learned change of timing and heft meant that I could raise the front over any obstacle. Using a half crank timed with the motor boost to lift the wheel is another technique to be learned on an eMTB.
The E-Trailster felt vague compared to some other eMTB's I have on test. This could be due to a number of reasons: the small diameter tubes in the front triangle and the extra long rear end also seemed to create some flex, and I found lots of tire roll from the narrow rims. It also
feels sluggish for eMTB, but however vague the feel might have been, the E-Trailster is a good platform in terms of pure downhill speed, its suspension, and its ability to take lines that others can't.
Technical Report
SRAM's EX1 Drivetrain: SRAM's eMTB specific EX1 drivetrain is currently the best choice for these machines. The single shift lever prevents twisting and grinding the chain over several cogs and teeth under huge wattage and the big steps between the gears mean less shifting is needed.
RockShox Pike fork: The Pike has been a benchmark fork for a number of years. I was glad to see the RCT3 version specced with 150mm travel, although it performed as well as any other Pike I have used over the last few years, it was no match for the great rear suspension system.
Maxxis Forecaster Tires: No problems with the Maxxis Forecaster for its intended use of cross country riding or light trail outings. But give somebody a bike this capable and heavy, it will be the first thing to go. Heavier duty Schwalbe Magic Mary's with Vertstar/Trailstar rubber and Super Gravity casing fitted the bill.
Bergamont Idler Pulley: The idler pulley started chatting to us after a mere hundred kilometers on the bike, then screaming at me. Removal of the chain revealed a rough feeling bearing, but laying the bike on its side and soaking with oil calmed it down for the next 500km's and beyond. Even when running smoothly, the idler wheel adds extra noise to the drivetrain.
Pinkbike's Take: | The E-Trailster is a bit of a dark horse. Some might say that it has is cheap, outdated parts, it is ugly, and it lacks a posh, integrated battery. Turns out that none of that matters - the Berga is a monster. It's easy to ride, with bags of stability and grip. With a stiffer front end, some more travel, and some tweaks in its geometry, it could be unbelievable. It's currently the first choice to power out of the garage.— Paul Aston |
About the Reviewer Stats: Age: 31 • Height: 6'1” • Ape Index: +4" • Weight: 75kg • Industry affiliations / sponsors: None • Instagram:
astonatorPaul Aston is a racer and dirt-jumper at heart. Previously adding to the list of non-qualifiers at World Cup DH events, he attacked enduro before it was fashionable, then realized he was old and achy. From the UK, but often found residing in mainland Europe.
Ultimately, Pinkbike is a mountain bike website and e-mountain bikes fall (wait for it) within the mountain bike category (gasp!). Mountain bike manufacturers are making pedal bikes with electric assist for the purpose of mountain biking. As such, Pinkbike should cover them like any other category of mountain bike. Not your cup of tea? Sweet. Just don't read the article and scroll down until you find what interests you.
But, by all means, haters should keep clicking on the articles and drive up the article's view count. That'll show 'em!
Why don't we get also reviews of 80mm 29r HT xc bikes ? They are mountain bikes too, so they should be on Pinkbike
Are you able to beat 40 km with 1500m up?
So really, do you actually have backup of these stories that these bikes are bought by absolute beginners? My impression (from what I read, not seen) is that these bikes are bought as a second or third bike by enthusiasts, professional guides exploring new terrain and older riders who otherwise couldn't ride in their group or would require a disproportionate amount of recovery between rides. That said, I'm not from France. Maybe there there are more people with money to burn on something new and unknown.
That said, upselling is creating something of a bubble for some companies, one that I suspect will pop shortly enough and some of the panic/hype will die down with it - one brand manager admitted to me that through their ebike drive their unit numbers had remained static, but their bottom line was better as cost per unit was a lot higher. Although I guess that depends on market context, staying static in a downwards market could be a big success, I guess.
I think it's in hire bikes where ebikes could be massive - put down 30, 50 Euros, whatever and there is virtually no fitness barrier to going to experience some "mountain biking." I think this could be a very powerful way to get people into the sport and taking their first steps onto the slippery slope where a 5000 Euro bike is no longer unreasonable...
You may not "respect" me for that, but for me, the more you add people on trails, the more you have chance to encounter this kind unrespectful people. I love my land, its mountains and its trails so I'm concerned about anything threatening it. And I think that facilitating a lot the access of mountain areas to consumers/tourists is a bad idea.